Short answer
Hoya carnosa 'Variegata' is the white-margined wax plant that Philipp Franz von Siebold brought to Europe from Japan in the 1840s. It was first published in 1846 as a species, Hoya variegata [2][4], and is now treated as a synonym of H. carnosa at species rank and as an accepted cultivar under the cultivated plant code [1][5]. Its leaves carry a cream to white border, often flushed pink on new growth [10].
What is the correct name for the variegated wax plant?
The correct name is Hoya carnosa 'Variegata'. The International Cultivar Registration Authority (ICRA) for Hoya, the body that keeps the list of accepted cultivar names for the genus, records it as an accepted and established cultivar, adding that it was initially published as Hoya variegata and that at species rank this name is a heterotypic synonym of Hoya carnosa (L.f.) R.Br. [1]. A heterotypic synonym is one based on a different type specimen that botanists now place in the same species. The Kew-based checklist served through GBIF agrees: Hoya variegata Siebold ex C.Morren is listed as a synonym whose accepted name is Hoya carnosa [5].
The older names still appear on labels. The registry lists Hoya variegata Siebold ex C.Morr., Hoya carnosa var. variegata (Siebold ex C.Morren) L.H.Bailey and Hoya carnosa f. variegata (Siebold ex C.Morren) H.Hara as synonyms [1]. The International Plant Names Index (IPNI) gives the original place of publication as the Annales of the Ghent agricultural and botanical society, volume 2 (1846), page 401, plate 90 [4].
Why may a Latin word stand as a cultivar epithet when modern cultivar names may not be wholly Latin? The International Code of Nomenclature for Cultivated Plants (ICNCP) provides that the final Latin epithet of a name published at species rank or below is retained as the cultivar epithet when that taxon is later reclassified as a cultivar [7]. That is exactly the history of 'Variegata': a plant described as a species, reduced to synonymy, and kept as a named clone.
How did Siebold's plant reach Europe?
By ship from Japan, as one of a pair. A circular from the Utrecht nurserymen G. de Winter and J. G. Jongeling, reprinted in the Ghent Annales in 1848, says Siebold had two remarkable hoyas carried from Japan in 1845, the first imported to Europe; one had leaves spotted golden yellow (Hoya picta) and the other leaves striped, marbled and edged in pure white (Hoya variegata) [3]. The registry adds that the two nurserymen bought both of Siebold's novelties and propagated them by cuttings [1].
The two printed accounts do not agree on dates or money. The 1846 article says Hoya variegata was shown at the Ghent exhibition of March 1845, where it won a special medal, and that the stock was valued at 3,500 Dutch florins (7,407 francs) [2]. The 1848 circular instead places the medal, a large silver medal for the newest and most remarkable plant not in flower, at the Ghent show in summer 1846, and gives the purchase price for both plants as 3,000 florins [3]. The registry gives 1846 as the year of introduction and 1845 for the Ghent medal [1]. None of this changes the identity of the cultivar, but it explains why different dates circulate.
The registry also corrects the authorship story. Siebold is honoured in the author citation, and the editor Charles Morren published the account, but the registry notes that W. H. de Vriese, the Leiden botany professor, first described 'Variegata' and that Morren added to it [1].
What did the first description record, and what was missing?
Leaves only. The 1846 Latin and French diagnosis describes round, velvety-pubescent stems, round petioles (leaf stalks), and leaves that are ovate to almost round when young, later elliptic to lanceolate and pointed, with one side of the base longer than the other, thick and variegated, and it closes with the words "flowers unknown" [2]. The editors explained that the leaves, washed, spotted and streaked with white and set off by pink peduncles, were judged worth a plate without waiting for flowers [2]. A peduncle is the short, persistent spur from which a hoya's flower clusters arise.
The flowers came seven years later. The registry records that 'Variegata' bloomed in 1853 in the greenhouse of Prince Frederick of the Netherlands, and that de Vriese then described leaves variegated with white, the margin often pink, reddish petioles, reddish-brown peduncles and a fleshy corolla pink on both sides [1]. The registry treats the 1846 engraving as the nomenclatural type, the reference image that fixes how the name is applied [1].
How do you recognise 'Variegata', and which plants came from it?
The pale tissue is on the margin. North Carolina State's plant toolbox describes 'Variegata' leaves as having creamy-white margins, sometimes tinged pink [10]. The 1846 plate and the 1853 description both stress pink flushing on the edge of young leaves and on the stalks [1][2], so a pink edge alone does not separate 'Variegata' from its descendants.
Most of the familiar variegated carnosa clones descend from it. Barnell Cobia's 1969 patent for the plant later named 'Tricolor' says the new variety resembled 'Variegata' and an unnamed variety generally considered an improved strain of 'Variegata' [8]. In a 2024 interview published by Stemma Journal, a member of the Cobia nursery's staff states that the KRIMSON QUEEN line was a mutation from Hoya carnosa 'Variegata' and that the unpatented 'Verna Jeanette' was also a sport from 'Variegata' [9]. A sport is a shoot that arises with a heritable difference and is fixed by cuttings. 'Tricolor' differs in having red to red-purple stems and petioles and a dark overcast on the green centre of new leaves [8]; see 'Tricolor' and 'Argentea Picta' for those lines.
What did 1846 growers advise, and does the wild species agree?
The 1846 culture note is short and still sound. It describes the hoya as suitable for warm, temperate or cool glasshouses, asks for a substantial soil of leaf mould mixed with clay, says shade and half shade suit it, asks for moderate watering, and propagates it by cuttings under bell jars in warm tan bark [2]. Those cuttings under a closed glass are the same method the registry describes for the first stock plants in Utrecht [1].
The wild parent explains why shade and moderate water work. Kew's Plants of the World Online (POWO) gives Hoya carnosa a native range from southern China to Laos and from southern Kyushu in Japan to Taiwan, as a climbing epiphyte or lithophyte (a plant rooted on bark or rock rather than in soil) of the subtropical biome [6]. In a Taiwanese rainforest, Martin and colleagues found that thick H. carnosa leaves had lower chlorophyll concentrations and higher chlorophyll a/b ratios than thin ones, a typical sun and shade response [13]. In 'Variegata' the white margin contributes no chlorophyll at all, so the green centre carries the plant, which is one reason the 1846 advice of shade rather than full sun is a safe default for keeping the white tissue unscorched.
Is the variegated wax plant on the ASPCA list?
Not under that name as a hoya. The ASPCA toxic and non-toxic plant database has an entry called Variegated Wax Plant, but it is labelled Echeveria sp. and listed as non-toxic to dogs and cats [11]; it refers to a succulent rosette, not to Hoya carnosa 'Variegata'. The species itself appears under Honey Plant, with Wax Plant as an additional common name, labelled Hoya carnosa and listed as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses [12]. The ASPCA does not list cultivars separately, so the species entry is the relevant one for 'Variegata'.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hoya variegata a separate species?
No. It was published as a species in 1846 [4], but the Kew checklist via GBIF treats Hoya variegata Siebold ex C.Morren as a synonym of Hoya carnosa [5]. The plant is now named as the cultivar Hoya carnosa 'Variegata' [1].
Who introduced Hoya carnosa 'Variegata'?
Philipp Franz von Siebold brought it from Japan; the Utrecht nurserymen de Winter and Jongeling bought it and propagated it [3]. The registry notes that W. H. de Vriese wrote the first description, published by Charles Morren in 1846 [1].
Is 'Variegata' the same as Krimson Queen?
No. KRIMSON QUEEN was a trade name for 'Tricolor', which arose in Cobia's Florida nursery from a sport of 'Variegata' [9]. 'Tricolor' has redder stems and petioles and pink-flushed margins on young leaves that are more intense than in 'Variegata' [8].
Why are the edges of new 'Variegata' leaves pink?
Pink flushing of the margin and reddish petioles were recorded in the 1853 description written when the plant first flowered [1]. The colour appears in young growth and fades as the leaf matures, leaving the cream margin described by extension sources [10].
Does Hoya carnosa 'Variegata' flower?
Yes. It was unknown in flower when described in 1846 [2], and first bloomed in 1853 in the Netherlands, when de Vriese recorded a fleshy corolla pink on both sides and a white corona with purple centres [1].