Short answer
Partly. Many hoyas, including Hoya carnosa and H. kerrii, have fleshy water-storing leaves and run crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), a night-time form of photosynthesis also found in cacti [2] [3]. But Flora of China describes Hoya leaves as fleshy, papery or membranous [7], so the genus is not uniformly succulent. Within H. carnosa, a thicker leaf is not a stronger CAM leaf: thickness follows sun or shade [1].
What does succulent actually mean for a leaf?
A succulent leaf is one built to hold a large reserve of water in living tissue, usually in big thin-walled cells with large vacuoles (the water-filled sacs that occupy most of a plant cell). There is no single agreed measurement. Martin, Hsu and Lin, working on Hoya carnosa in Taiwan, note that a precise definition of tissue succulence has never been universally accepted, and that leaf thickness is the simple, if simplistic, stand-in most studies use [1].
A broader comparison gives the scale of the difference. Across 132 species, Mozzi and colleagues found that succulent leaves held roughly ten times more water per unit of leaf area, and roughly ten times more water relative to dry mass, than non-succulent leaves of the same specific leaf area [10]. That is the functional test that matters for a hoya: does the leaf carry a reserve that keeps the plant working when its roots get nothing? For the thick-leaved species the answer is clearly yes, which is why a dry Hoya carnosa leaf goes soft and wrinkled long before the plant dies (see soft and wrinkled hoya leaves).
Are all hoya leaves fleshy?
No. The Flora of China genus description covers epiphytic or epilithic (rock-dwelling) climbers whose leaves are fleshy, papery or membranous [7], three very different textures inside one genus. Kleijn and van Donkelaar, summarising leaf variation for the whole genus, set the range from herbaceous leaves in Hoya multiflora to extremely succulent ones in H. australis subsp. rupicola, and warn that thickness, like leaf size, shifts with the conditions a plant experiences [6]. They also point out a field sign of succulence: leaf venation becomes obscure in species with more succulent leaves, such as H. diversifolia [6]. Water tissue swells between the veins and hides them.
Some species sit at the far end. Hoya spectatissima, a lithophytic liana of limestone karst in Yunnan described in 2023, has leaves 2.5 to 3 mm thick [8]. The Flora of China key separates H. kerrii partly by the same sign, an obovate to orbicular blade with lateral veins obscure and a notched tip [7]. Hoya kerrii is native from Indo-China to western Malesia according to the World Checklist of Vascular Plants record for the species [11]. For how it grows in the wild, see Hoya kerrii.
Do hoyas use CAM, the photosynthesis of succulents?
Many do. Crassulacean acid metabolism, named after the stonecrop family where it was first studied, is a way of photosynthesising with the stomata (leaf pores) open at night instead of by day. Carbon dioxide taken in during the cool night is fixed into malic acid and stored in the vacuoles; after sunrise the stomata close and the acid is broken down to release carbon dioxide for ordinary photosynthesis behind sealed pores. Night opening loses far less water than day opening [1].
Winter and colleagues screened Australian rainforest epiphytes by their carbon isotope ratio (CAM plants carry a recognisable signature of heavy carbon) and found CAM in Asclepiadaceae in two genera that usually have fleshy leaves, Hoya and Dischidia [2]. In the same survey, leaves thicker than about 1 mm gave values indicative of pronounced CAM in most species [2]. A recent survey of CAM across land plants places the trait in the Marsdenieae clade formed by those two genera of succulent epiphytic vines [3]. In the milkweed subfamily as a whole, CAM has probably arisen at least three times, in succulent-leaved vines and in cactus-like stem succulents [3], so a hoya's CAM is a parallel invention, not an inheritance from cacti.
The link between thick leaves and CAM is old knowledge within the genus. Martin and colleagues cite a 1960 report by Nuernbergk of CAM in a succulent Hoya species while a non-succulent species lacked it [1]. That pattern fits the leaf range above: the fleshy-leaved hoyas are the ones to expect CAM in, while thin-leaved species such as H. multiflora have not been shown to share it in any source located for this page.
Is a thicker hoya leaf a stronger CAM leaf?
Not within a species. Martin, Hsu and Lin measured ten wild Hoya carnosa plants and ten of Dischidia formosana at about 600 m in the Fushan forest of north-eastern Taiwan, comparing overnight acid gain against the thickness of each leaf [1]. Nearly every leaf ran CAM, but the degree of CAM was not correlated with leaf thickness [1]. What did track thickness was chlorophyll: thick leaves had less chlorophyll and higher chlorophyll a/b ratios, the classic profile of sun leaves, so the authors concluded that differences in succulence reflected sun and shade adaptation, not photosynthetic pathway [1].
Glasshouse work points the same way. Adams, Osmond and Sharkey grew H. carnosa under five light levels and saw progressive decreases in leaf thickness, night-time acid accumulation and other activity with increasing shade [5]. Plants grown under full glasshouse light were the one exception: they showed signs of photoinhibition, damage to the photosynthetic machinery from more light than it can use [5]. A wider review of 81 CAM species found that neither leaf thickness nor mesophyll traits explained the degree of CAM expression across families [4]. The practical reading for a grower is that a hoya's leaves thicken where it gets more light, and that a plant moved abruptly from shade into full sun can be harmed before it has rebuilt its leaves.
What do stored water and CAM buy a hoya in a drought?
Time. Rayder and Ting held Hoya carnosa without water and found that after 10 to 12 days of severe stress the plants switched from normal CAM to CAM-idling, closing their stomata almost completely while still cycling acid each day and night [9]. In that state the leaf recycles carbon dioxide from its own respiration and loses almost no water. The plants held the idling mode for at least eight weeks and returned to full CAM within a week of rewatering [9].
That capacity matches where CAM is most common among epiphytes. Winter and colleagues found it most prevalent in exposed microhabitats with relatively high light and short but frequent periods of water stress [2]. For a canopy hoya that means a branch that dries within days of each shower, not a desert that stays dry for months. The water budget, rather than the label, is what shapes watering: see watering hoyas for the schedule that follows from it.
So should a hoya be grown like a succulent?
Only in part. The fleshy-leaved hoyas, among them H. carnosa, H. kerrii, H. australis and H. spectatissima, tolerate dry spells because their leaves carry water and their CAM metabolism can idle [9] [6]. They are still epiphytes or rock climbers with adventitious roots (roots that grow from the stem nodes) that grip bark, moss or rock [6], not desert plants with deep or swollen roots. Roots on a branch or rock face sit in a thin, airy layer that drains as soon as rain stops, and a free-draining epiphyte mix reproduces that better than a dense potting soil kept moist.
The thin-leaved species are a different case. A papery-leaved hoya has little reserve to fall back on [7], and treating it to the long dry intervals that suit H. kerrii will cost it leaves. Light follows the same logic: thick, sun-adapted leaves come from bright conditions [1], and the photoinhibition seen in H. carnosa under full glasshouse light [5] argues for raising light in steps rather than all at once.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hoya kerrii a succulent?
In the functional sense, yes. Its obovate to orbicular leaves have obscure veins and a notched tip in the Flora of China description [7], a sign of thick water-storing tissue, and fleshy-leaved hoyas are the group in which CAM photosynthesis has been recorded [2].
Are hoyas related to cacti?
No. Hoyas belong to the milkweed subfamily of Apocynaceae. CAM photosynthesis has probably arisen at least three times within that subfamily alone, in succulent-leaved vines and cactus-like stem succulents [3], so hoyas reached the same water-saving chemistry independently.
Does a thick-leaved Hoya carnosa photosynthesise differently from a thin-leaved one?
Not in pathway. In wild Hoya carnosa in Taiwan, nearly all leaves ran CAM and the amount did not correlate with leaf thickness; thick leaves were sun leaves, thin ones shade leaves [1].
How long can a succulent hoya go without water?
In one experiment, Hoya carnosa shifted to a water-conserving CAM-idling state after 10 to 12 days of severe drought, held it for at least eight weeks, and returned to normal CAM within a week of rewatering [9]. Survival is not the same as growth, so long droughts are a fallback, not a schedule.
Is cactus mix right for a hoya?
The goal is fast drainage and air around adventitious roots that grip bark and rock in the wild [6]. Gritty cactus mix drains well but holds little, so bark-based epiphyte mixes are closer to the habitat, especially for thin-leaved species with small water reserves [7].