Short answer
First rub the leaf. Black film that wipes off is sooty mould growing on honeydew from sap-feeding insects such as mealybugs [1]. Black that is part of the leaf is dead tissue: blackening from tips and edges or greasy patches days after a cold night is chilling injury [3]; black that spreads up from the soil line with soft, brown roots is rot [10]; a dry dead patch on the sunny face is sunburn [5].
Does the black wipe off the hoya leaf?
The quickest test separates two unrelated problems. Wipe a black leaf with a damp cloth. If the black comes off and leaves green, glossy leaf underneath, it is sooty mould: fungi that, as UC IPM puts it, do not infect plants but grow on plant parts and other surfaces where honeydew deposits accumulate [1]. Honeydew is the sugary excrement of sap-feeding insects, and the list of producers includes aphids, leafhoppers and mealybugs [1]. NC State Extension names mealybugs as a common problem on Hoya carnosa [2], so a sooty hoya usually has mealybugs above the blackened leaves, tucked into leaf axils, around peduncles (the woody flower spurs) or on the leaf undersides.
Sooty mould does no direct damage, but a heavy coat shades the leaf and reduces photosynthesis [1]. UC IPM notes it can be washed off with a strong stream of water or with soap and water [1]; the lasting fix is removing the insects. If the black does not wipe off, the tissue itself has died, and the rest of this page applies.
What does cold damage look like on a hoya?
Chilling injury is damage done by cold above freezing. UF/IFAS defines a chilling temperature as any temperature cold enough to cause injury but not cold enough to freeze the plant, usually from just above 32°F to 59°F [3]. Cold makes cell membranes rigid and leaky; once they fail, the cell contents oxidise and the tissue darkens. No chilling trial has been published for Hoya, so the UF/IFAS foliage trials are the best guide to what to expect. In Spathiphyllum, chilling injury started from leaf tips and edges and progressed inward, with injured areas becoming necrotic, then turning black, and finally drying up completely [3]. In Aglaonema, dark and greasy patches appeared between the midvein and leaf margin two days after chilling [4]. In both, mature leaves were more sensitive than young ones [3], and longer exposure did more harm than a short one [3].
On a hoya that means black that appears a day or several days after a cold night, on the leaves that touched the window glass or sat in a draught, usually the older leaves first, and with dark, water-soaked or greasy-looking patches that later dry and harden. The leaves on the warm side of the same plant are untouched.
How cold is too cold differs by species and follows their native climate. UF/IFAS says Hoya can be grown outdoors as long as it is not exposed to temperatures below 45°F [5], NC State says to bring H. carnosa indoors when nights fall below 50°F [2], and the RHS sets a minimum night temperature of 10°C (50°F) for Hoya carnosa [6]. H. carnosa itself is a subtropical species whose native range runs from southern China to Laos and from southern Kyushu to Taiwan [7]. Hoya lacunosa, by contrast, ranges from southern Myanmar to western and central Malesia and grows primarily in the wet tropical biome [8], and Hoya kerrii comes from Indo-China to western Malesia [9]. Lowland species like these evolved without cool nights, so blackened leaves on a lacunosa after a night near 50°F are far more likely to be chilling than they would be on a carnosa.
When does the black start at the soil line?
Rot is the other main cause, and it starts below, not on the leaf face. UConn Extension describes Phytophthora root and stem rot as producing brownish-black cankers at the soil line and brown, diseased roots, and notes that the water moulds Pythium and Phytophthora are favoured by excessive moisture [10]. The RHS lists dropping leaves, blackening leaves and dieback among the hoya problems it links to waterlogged compost or cold winters [6]. On a hoya the pattern is distinctive: a stem darkening upward from the mix, leaves going black from the petiole (leaf stalk) end rather than from the tip, and tissue that is soft and wet to the touch rather than dry.
Cold and wet compound each other. UConn notes that Thielaviopsis black root rot is most severe at cool temperatures and in wet soils, with roots that become black and rotted [10]. A hoya watered on its summer schedule in a cold room is therefore set up for both chilling and rot at once. Unpot and look: white, well-branched roots mean the black above is a leaf problem; brown or black roots that shed their outer layer mean the black is coming from below. See the root rot page for salvage.
Can sun burn a hoya leaf black?
Yes. UF/IFAS warns that too much direct sun can burn hoya foliage [5]. The physiology is photoinhibition, damage to the light-harvesting machinery when a leaf receives more light than it can use. In a controlled study, Hoya carnosa grown under full glasshouse light apparently experienced photoinhibition [11]. A leaf that cannot dissipate the excess bleaches first, to pale yellow or white, then the dead patch turns brown to black and dries papery. Burns sit on the part of the leaf facing the light, often in the middle of the blade, with a sharp edge, and they typically appear within days of a move to a brighter spot or of the first strong spring sun through glass.
Do not confuse burn with the protective colour change that comes first. Kleijn and van Donkelaar describe the leaves of Hoya brevialata in Sulawesi as light green, yellowish to bright red when very exposed [12]. Red and maroon flushing on a sun-grown hoya is pigment shading the leaf; it is reversible and harmless. Black, dry, sunken tissue is not. The sun stress guide covers the line between the two.
Could black spots be a virus or mites?
Black spots and rings that follow no cold, wet or sun event can be viral. On a Hoya calycina in Honolulu, Capsicum chlorosis virus produced leaves with concentric chlorotic and necrotic rings surrounding sunken, necrotic lesions typical of tospovirus infection [13]. A tospovirus cannot be cured; isolate the plant and do not propagate from it. Flat mites cause browner, crusty damage instead: in hoya collections, petioles develop crusty brown damage and, as infestation worsens, dry brown scab-like damage spreads around the leaf base, petiole and veins, often visible only on the underside of thick leaves [14].
| Black on the hoya | Texture | Starts at | Cause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Film that wipes off | Powdery, sooty | Leaf surface below insects | Sooty mould on honeydew |
| Patches days after cold | Greasy, then dry | Tips, edges, leaves near glass | Chilling injury |
| Spreading from stem base | Soft, wet | Soil line, petiole end | Root and stem rot |
| Sharp-edged dead patch | Dry, papery | Sun-facing blade | Sunburn |
| Rings around sunken spots | Firm leaf | Scattered | Virus |
Dead black hoya tissue never turns green again, so judge any change by the leaves that grow next. Cut rotted stems back to firm, pale tissue; leave chilled or sunburned leaves in place until the plant has new growth, because the surviving green parts still feed it.
Frequently asked questions
Why are my Hoya lacunosa leaves turning black?
Hoya lacunosa grows primarily in the wet tropical biome from southern Myanmar to central Malesia [8], so cold is the first suspect: blackening that appears days after a cool night near a window is chilling injury. Check the roots too, since cold, wet mix also rots them [10].
Can a black hoya leaf recover?
No. Blackened tissue is dead. In chilling trials, injured areas turned black and finally dried up completely [3]. A leaf with only a small dead patch can stay on the plant and keep photosynthesising with its green part.
Is black on hoya leaves always a disease?
No. Sooty mould is a fungus growing on insect honeydew on the leaf surface and does not infect the plant [1]. It wipes off; the real target is the mealybugs or other sap-feeders producing the honeydew.
What temperature causes hoya cold damage?
No hoya-specific threshold has been measured. Extension guidance puts the safe floor for Hoya carnosa at 45 to 50°F [5], and lowland species such as Hoya kerrii, native from Indo-China to western Malesia [9], deserve a warmer margin.