Short answer
Hoya fraterna Blume is an accepted species, published in 1849 [1][2], that Blume named for its close likeness to H. coriacea [3][11]. Kew's checklist gives its native range as Java and Sabah in Borneo [1]. It is a strong climber of riverine and ridge forest with shiny leaves and umbels of deep gold, very hairy flowers [12][13]. The thick-leaved plant long grown under the name is placed in H. meliflua by Rodda (2016) and Kew's checklist [9][10].
What did Blume describe as Hoya fraterna?
Hoya fraterna Blume is an accepted species in Kew's World Checklist of Vascular Plants (WCVP), which cites its place of publication as Rumphia 4: 32 (1849) [1]. The International Plant Names Index gives the same citation and the original locality as Java [2]. The author was Carl Ludwig Blume (1796 to 1862) [2], who had published Hoya coriacea from Java in 1826 [6].
The name first appears inside Blume's account of H. coriacea in Rumphia. There he wrote that he had found a very closely allied species, which he called H. fraterna, in limestone hills around Kuripan, and that it differed in its smaller flowers, much longer calyx segments and the obtuse outer angle of the staminal corona lobes [3]. The calyx is the ring of five sepals under the flower; the staminal corona is the fleshy five-pointed star at the flower's centre. Kloppenburg's 1993 history of the two names quotes the fuller Latin diagnosis from Blume's Museum Botanicum Lugduno-Batavum of 1849, which repeats that the species is very close to H. coriacea and grows in calcareous ground at Kuripan in western Java [6]. Mark Randal's 2007 account treats the Rumphia mention as too slight to count as the publication and dates the description to the Museum Botanicum [12]. Kew and IPNI cite Rumphia 4: 32, which IPNI dates to late October 1849 [1][2]; Kloppenburg's chronology lists that Rumphia entry as 1848, name only [6].
Ted Green, writing in 1998, translated fraterna as brother in Latin and explained that Blume chose it because the plant looked so much like H. coriacea [11]. The Naturalis Biodiversity Center holds a sheet of H. fraterna from Java (U.1102611) collected by Kuhl and van Hasselt; the record gives no collection date [4].
Where does Hoya fraterna grow in the wild?
WCVP gives the native range as Borneo (Sabah) and Jawa, and classes the plant as a climber of the wet tropical biome [1]. WCVP lists no other region for it. Its close relative H. coriacea is listed far more widely, from Thailand to Malesia [14].
The Bornean half of the range was found late. Green reported that the true fraterna had not been recollected, or at least not recognised, for 150 years, until Tony Lamb found it in 1993 at Uluapinapin in Sabah, at about 2,600 ft near the Apinapin River [11]. Green first took it for H. coriacea. Lamb's cutting grew into a large flowering vine at the Tenom Orchid Center, and photographs, pickled flowers and a cutting from that plant let Green identify it as Blume's species [11].
Lamb and co-authors, in their 2014 survey of the hoyas of Sabah, describe H. fraterna as a very strong climber that reaches over 10 m into riverine trees and also grows in ridge forest in the Crocker Range [13]. They cite Crocker Range specimens Lamb AL 2139/2011 and AL 1724/2009 in the Sandakan herbarium (SAN) [13], and recorded small moths on its flowers in the wild, one photographed at 800 m and identified by them as a species of Trabala [13]. Green called it a terrestrial, tropical vine [11], meaning a climber rooted in the ground rather than an epiphyte perched on branches.
How is Hoya fraterna told from H. coriacea and H. chewiorum?
The species has two close relatives with which it is easily confused, and the published differences sit mostly in the leaf surface, the corolla hairs and the corona.
| Trait | H. fraterna | Relative |
|---|---|---|
| Leaf surface | Shiny [11] | H. coriacea: dull [11] |
| Corona lobes | Strongly upright, not curved outward [12] | H. coriacea: curving outward into a pointed hook [12] |
| Flower colour | Deep gold [12] | H. coriacea: pale chartreuse [12] |
| Leaf size | Lamina to 18 by 7 cm [13] | H. chewiorum: to 6.8 by 3.4 cm [13] |
| Flowers per umbel | 20 to 40, up to 60 in the Crocker Range [13] | H. chewiorum: 15 to 30 [13] |
| Corolla lobes | Very long silvery hairs [13] | H. chewiorum: finely pubescent [13] |
Green summed the plant up as resembling H. coriacea in growth, with milky sap and stems that do not root along their length, but differing in flower shape [11]. Lamb and co-authors add a finer character: in H. fraterna a lace-like anther membrane covers the stigma head and hides the pollinia, while in H. chewiorum the membrane is narrow and the pollinia are not always covered [13]. The pollinia are the paired waxy pollen packets that a visiting insect carries away. For the smaller-leaved Sabah relative, see the Hoya chewiorum page, and for the dull-leaved Javan species, Hoya coriacea.
Not everyone has kept the two Javan names apart. Ruurd van Donkelaar, in a 1989 article translated in Fraterna in 1996, wrote that Koorders (1912) and Backer and Bakhuizen (1949) treated H. fraterna as a small form and synonym of H. coriacea, and that Blume's type at Leiden supported them [8]. Kloppenburg asked in 1993 how the two type sheets could now be found nearly identical when Blume had named three differences, and wrote that the Leiden type sheet of H. fraterna was not the plant growers knew under that name [6]. WCVP accepts both species [1][14].
Why was the 'Hoya fraterna' of gardens a different plant?
For over 100 years, in Green's words, the name Hoya fraterna was used for a plant that Green and Kloppenburg did not regard as Blume's species [6][11]. That usage goes back to plate 4684 of Curtis's Botanical Magazine, dated 1 December 1852 [6][7]. Hooker's text says the plant was found in Java by Blume and since by Thomas Lobb, who sent it to Veitch's nursery at Exeter, where it grew vigorously in the stove house [5]. Hooker described leaves up to a foot long, singularly thick and firmly fleshy, and a pale buff corolla with five red-brown blotches that were always wet and clammy, which he put down to a flow of honey from the crown [5]. He called it the Thick-leaved Hoya [5].
Hoya specialists questioned what the plate shows from 1989 on. Kloppenburg pointed out that Lobb visited Borneo and the neighbourhood of Manila on his 1848 expedition, and offered the guess that the plant was Philippine and the same as H. meliflua or close to it [6]. Ruurd van Donkelaar's 1989 article on H. diversifolia and its relatives, reprinted in translation by Albert Hofman in Fraterna in 1996, read the plate instead as a plant of the H. diversifolia type, which it said should be H. diversifolia or something close to it [8]. Green named the cultivated plant H. meliflua subsp. fraterna in 1995, keeping the epithet for its use of over 100 years [9][11], and in a correction the same year added that its type is the plate in Curtis's Botanical Magazine, Tab. 4684 [7].
In 2016 Michele Rodda listed the plate name as Hoya fraterna non Blume (Hooker 1852), that is, a misapplied name, chose a Kew specimen grown in June 1864 as epitype, and sank Green's subspecies into H. meliflua [9]. WCVP lists H. meliflua subsp. fraterna T.Green as a synonym under H. meliflua subsp. meliflua [10]. Under Rodda's treatment the plant of the 1852 plate falls in H. meliflua [9]; the full story of that name is on the Hoya meliflua page.
What do the flowers of the true Hoya fraterna look like?
Randal gives the clearest account from cultivated plants. The umbels carry up to 50 or more flowers of a deep rich gold, with very hairy corollas and a pink and ivory corona [12]. The sepals are long and pointed and wrap each developing bud in a green jacket, so that a young H. fraterna bud looks like an unopened tulip [12]. Newly opened flowers look rotate, that is flat and wheel-shaped, and over a day or two the corolla lobes reflex until they point straight backwards [12].
The inflorescence of H. fraterna is positively geotropic, meaning the peduncle (the flower stalk) points downward and the umbel hangs below it, as Lamb's photograph from the Crocker Range shows [13]. Green found that it flowers year-round with little to no fragrance [11]. Randal agrees that scent is weak and reports that some growers notice an overripe peach smell, which may vary with conditions [12].
How does its forest ecology translate into care?
Kew classes H. fraterna as a climber of the wet tropical biome [1], and Lamb found it climbing riverine trees [13]. The published growing notes come from two specialist growers. Randal writes that it grows well in intermediate temperatures of 13 to 35 C (55 to 95 F) and performs well in bright indirect light, with no direct sun beyond an hour or two in early morning or late afternoon [12]. In lower light it grows lushly but flowers less [12].
Randal notes that its leaves are rather thin for a Hoya, so it dries out and wilts faster than many, and that the soil should never dry out completely, since drought blasts the flower buds [12]. Green made the same point: the leaves are not succulent, the plant should not be allowed to dry out fully, and the leathery feel of the leaf tells when to water [11]. He advised a loose mix, moderate sunlight but not full sun, and regular feeding with a balanced fertilizer [11].
Internodes reach 20 cm, and Randal gives leaves of 12 cm to reportedly 25 cm or more [12], and the stems do not root along their length [11]. Randal advises a sturdy trellis or support at least three feet (about 90 cm) tall, with new stems wound around it horizontally to keep the plant densely clothed [12]. Randal adds that its strong root system may benefit from potting up sooner than most hoyas [12].
Frequently asked questions
Is Hoya fraterna the same as Hoya meliflua subsp. fraterna?
No. Blume's H. fraterna is an accepted species of Java and Sabah [1]. The subspecies was Green's name for the thick-leaved plant figured as H. fraterna in 1852 [7], which Rodda sank into H. meliflua in 2016 [9].
Where is Hoya fraterna native?
Kew's checklist gives Borneo (Sabah) and Java [1]. Blume found it on limestone hills around Kuripan in Java [3], and Tony Lamb recollected it in Sabah in 1993 [11]; it climbs riverine trees in the Crocker Range [13].
How do you tell Hoya fraterna from Hoya coriacea?
H. fraterna has shiny leaves where H. coriacea has dull ones [11], upright blunt corona lobes rather than outward-hooked ones, and deep gold rather than pale chartreuse flowers [12].
Are Hoya fraterna flowers fragrant?
Barely. Green found that it flowers year-round with little to no fragrance [11]. Randal reports that some growers notice an overripe peach scent, which may vary with growing conditions and plant health [12].
Should Hoya fraterna dry out between waterings?
Not completely. Its leaves are thin for a hoya and it wilts faster than many species; drought can blast the flower buds [12]. Green judged watering by the leathery feel of the leaf [11].