Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f. · ← Hoya Updated 2026-10-19

HOYA

Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f.

A species described from one flowering sheet collected west of Bogor in 1920, and argued over by growers since.


Short answer

Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f. is an accepted species, published in Blumea in 1950 from a single specimen collected in 1920 at 800 m on Mt. Tjipoetih near Tjiampea, West Java [1][2][3]. Kew's checklist gives its range as Sumatra to Java and its life form as a climbing epiphyte or lithophyte of the wet tropics [1]. Which plant in cultivation is the true species has long been disputed, chiefly against the Bornean H. meredithii [6].

Who described Hoya vitellinoides, and from what specimen?

Kew's World Checklist of Vascular Plants (WCVP) accepts Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f. and cites its place of publication as Blumea 6: 381 (1950) [1]. The International Plant Names Index (IPNI) dates the issue to 3 April 1950, gives the original distribution as Java, and identifies the author as Reinier Cornelis Bakhuizen van den Brink (1911 to 1987) [2]. The name appeared in his Notes on the Flora of Java, VI, in a run of new Javan hoyas that also included H. tenggerensis and H. tjadasmalangensis [3].

The type is one gathering, number 4181, from Mt. Tjipoetih near Tjiampea in the former residency of Batavia, at 800 m, in flower in September [3]. The protologue, the original published description, cites the sheet at Leiden (L) [3]. Naturalis now catalogues it as L 0004347, collected on 24 September 1920, and records the collector as Bakhuizen van den Brink Sr [4]. The 2019 Sumatra checklist by Rahayu and Rodda cites the same sheet as holotype, the specimen that fixes the name [5]. A duplicate of number 4181 is held at Herbarium Bogoriense as BO:110969, its label giving the habitat in one Dutch word, verspreid (scattered) [7]. Ted Green, writing in Fraterna in 2011, explained the epithet: Bakhuizen named the plant vitellinoides, like vitellina, because it resembled H. vitellina Blume [6].

What does the 1950 description record?

Bakhuizen described a glabrous-stemmed climber with oblong leaves, obtuse at the base and shortly, sharply acuminate (drawn out to a point), very sparsely and very shortly hairy on both surfaces, thickly coriaceous (leathery) and penninerved, with 4 to 6 conspicuous lateral nerves [3]. Green's English translation gives the blades as 14 to 16 cm long and 7 to 7.5 cm wide on a thick petiole 7.5 to 10 mm long [6].

The flowering material was thin. Bakhuizen had not seen the inflorescence: the Latin says inflorescentia mihi ignota [3]. The pedicel (flower stalk) is slender, rather densely hairy and 2.5 cm long, and the calyx lobes are narrowly triangular, ciliate and about 1 mm long [3]. The corolla, the fused petals, he gave with a question mark as almost flat, yellow when dry and about 8 mm across, its elliptic-oblong lobes 3.5 mm long and, under a strong lens, sparsely covered inside with minute round scales or stellate (star-shaped) hairs [3][6].

The corona, the fleshy star of five scales over the stamens, carried his diagnosis. Its lobes are narrow and roughly triangular-cultriform (knife-shaped) in outline, strongly keeled on top, and broadly triangular at the inner angle [3]. The pollinia, the paired waxy pollen masses, are oblanceolate and almost twice as long as the translator arms that join them, with no caudicle, and the follicles (seed pods) were not seen [3]. He closed by saying the species resembles Hoya vitellina somewhat but differs in the corona scales and the pollination apparatus [3].

Where does Hoya vitellinoides grow wild?

WCVP gives the range as Sumatera to Jawa, lists the areas Jawa and Sumatera, and records the species as a climbing epiphyte or lithophyte (growing on trees or on rock) of the wet tropical biome [1]. The type locality lies in western Java, at 800 m [3]. Backer's key in the Flora of Java (1965), as Green quoted it, still knew the plant only from Mt. Tjiputih west of Bogor, in forest at 800 m [6]. A second Javan gathering at Leiden, Kostermans 19017 of 21 July 1961, comes from Bantam in West Java, its locality given as "Nera waterfall Bitung of Tjidanen near lake Donan" [8]. For Sumatra, Rahayu and Rodda list H. vitellinoides in their 2019 checklist of the island's 43 Hoya taxa, citing the Javan holotype [5].

No published source traced for this page records the host trees, light or soil at either Javan site of H. vitellinoides. The Bogor label's single word, scattered [7], is the only habitat note in the specimen records of the type gathering [4][7].

Which plant is the true Hoya vitellinoides?

Green called it a running argument. In his 2011 Fraterna article Will the real Hoya vitellinoides please stand up? he wrote that the two names most mixed up in collections are H. meredithii and H. vitellinoides [6]. He reported that the Leiden sheet had not been located, that Chris Burton found the Bogor sheet of number 4181 labelled H. coriacea, with only six flowers, and that flowers from it were mailed to Dale Kloppenburg in 1990 [6]. Green offered plants from Sabah as what he thought the true species: he photographed a Clemens collection from Mt. Kinabalu at the New York Botanical Garden, and described a 1999 collection on a dead tree by a stream in the Crocker Range [6]. He added that one faction considers H. meredithii to be the true H. vitellinoides, and that he never had [6].

The checklists draw the line differently. WCVP places H. meredithii in Borneo (Sabah and Sarawak) [9] and H. vitellinoides in Sumatra and Java only [1]. Rodda's 2017 index, which aims to list all Hoya taxa occurring on Borneo with their types, has an entry for H. meredithii, whose type is a cultivated plant originally from Bau, Sarawak (Meredith 80-05), vouchered in Hawaii as Green 81-002, and none for H. vitellinoides [10]. One herbarium sheet links the two names: a New York sheet named H. vitellinoides, Green 92826 of August 1992, carries the note original collection Meredith 80-05 from Sarawak [11], the same collection that Rodda cites for the H. meredithii type [10]. This page sets out these records side by side and does not decide between them.

How is it told from Hoya vitellina and its relatives?

The protologue separates it from H. vitellina on the corona scales and pollinarium, not the leaves [3]. Green added a leaf contrast: H. vitellina leaves are usually about half the size, with the same substance [6]. His 1999 table of averaged leaves gives H. vitellinoides as hard, flexible, flat and smooth-edged, 2.5 by 7.5 inches, against a mostly boat-shaped H. vitellina leaf of 2.8 by 6.25 inches [12]. For the species itself see the Hoya vitellina page.

Both names sit in a wider group. Stemma Journal 4(2) counts H. vitellinoides in the Hoya finlaysonii complex, with H. callistophylla, H. clemensiorum and H. meredithii, whose near-identical, reflexed, yellow or cream flowers leave leaf size, secondary venation and leaf edge to separate them [13]. A DNA study reported in Fraterna in 2002 by Anne-Marie Lemay, using plants supplied by Kloppenburg, recovered H. nicholsoniae and H. vitellinoides as a sister pair, sharing yellowish flowers [14]; given the identity dispute, which clone was sampled is not stated in that report.

What does the record support for cultivation?

The documented biology is short: a climbing epiphyte or lithophyte of the wet tropics [1], known from forest at 800 m in West Java [3][6], with thick, leathery leaves [3].

Grower records describe the group rather than the type. Green wrote in 1999 that the finlaysonii group plants he grew flowered about two years from a 6 inch cutting, that their flowers seldom last more than a day or so, that the peduncles (flower-cluster stalks) are persistent, and that flowering can come at any time of year [12]. The register record for the cultivar 'Noelle', published as a suspected H. vitellinoides x H. vitellina cross, says that cultivar is not as heavily scented as H. vitellinoides [15]. A hand pollinator in the Philippines listed a H. vitellina x H. vitellinoides pod among eleven sterile hybrid pods in Stemma Journal 5(2) [16]. None of these notes says which clone of H. vitellinoides was grown.

Frequently asked questions

Is Hoya vitellinoides an accepted name?

Yes. Kew's World Checklist of Vascular Plants accepts Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f., published in Blumea 6: 381 (1950), with a native range of Sumatra to Java [1].

What does vitellinoides mean?

Like vitellina. Green wrote that Bakhuizen named it for its resemblance to Hoya vitellina Blume [6], and the protologue says it resembles that species somewhat but differs in the corona scales and pollination apparatus [3].

Is Hoya vitellinoides the same as Hoya meredithii?

Not in the checklists: WCVP accepts both, placing H. meredithii in Borneo [9] and H. vitellinoides in Sumatra and Java [1]. Green reported that one faction of growers treats H. meredithii as the true H. vitellinoides, a view he rejected [6].

Where was the type of Hoya vitellinoides collected?

On Mt. Tjipoetih near Tjiampea, west of Bogor in West Java, at 800 m, as number 4181, held at Leiden [3]. Naturalis dates the sheet L 0004347 to 24 September 1920 [4].

What colour are Hoya vitellinoides flowers?

The protologue gives a nearly flat corolla, yellow in the dried state and about 8 mm across [3]. Bakhuizen marked the colour and shape with a question mark, working from a dried sheet [3].

See an error, or have documentation we lack? Submissions open shortly. Corrections are reviewed against documentation before the record changes.

Sources

  1. Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f., World Checklist of Vascular Plants (ChecklistBank record 507252, linked to POWO) (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew (WCVP via ChecklistBank). https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:98734-1 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  2. Hoya vitellinoides Bakh.f., Blumea 6(2): 381 (1950), name record (n.d.). International Plant Names Index. https://www.ipni.org/n/98734-1 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  3. Notes on the Flora of Java, VI (R. C. Bakhuizen van den Brink f.), Blumea 6(2): 363 to 406 (Internet Archive scan) (1950-04-03). Blumea (Rijksherbarium, Leiden). https://archive.org/details/blumea-0006-5196-6-363-406 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  4. Hoya vitellinoides, type specimen L 0004347 (Bakhuizen van den Brink 4181), GBIF occurrence 2513083322 (n.d.). Naturalis Biodiversity Center via GBIF. https://www.gbif.org/occurrence/2513083322 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  5. Hoya of Sumatra, an updated checklist, three new species, and a new subspecies (S. Rahayu & M. Rodda), European Journal of Taxonomy 508: 1 to 23 (2019-01-01). European Journal of Taxonomy. https://doi.org/10.5852/ejt.2019.508 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  6. Will the real Hoya vitellinoides please stand up? (T. Green), Fraterna 24(4), October to December 2011 (Internet Archive item fraternaofficial2011unse) (2011-01-01). International Hoya Association. https://archive.org/details/fraternaofficial2011unse Accessed 2026-10-19.
  7. Hoya vitellinoides, Bakhuizen van den Brink 4181, Herbarium Bogoriense BO:110969, GBIF occurrence 4067108623 (n.d.). Herbarium Bogoriense (BRIN) via GBIF. https://www.gbif.org/occurrence/4067108623 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  8. Hoya vitellinoides, Kostermans 19017, L.2718336, GBIF occurrence 2514517008 (n.d.). Naturalis Biodiversity Center via GBIF. https://www.gbif.org/occurrence/2514517008 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  9. Hoya meredithii T.Green, World Checklist of Vascular Plants (ChecklistBank record 506959) (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew (WCVP via ChecklistBank). https://api.checklistbank.org/dataset/2232/taxon/506959/info Accessed 2026-10-19.
  10. Index of names and types of Hoya (Apocynaceae: Asclepiadoideae) of Borneo (M. Rodda), Gardens' Bulletin Singapore 69(1): 33 to 65 (2017-01-01). Singapore Botanic Gardens. https://doi.org/10.26492/gbs69(1).2017-02 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  11. Hoya vitellinoides, T. Green 92826 (NY 04192913), GBIF occurrence 2447312746 (n.d.). New York Botanical Garden via GBIF. https://www.gbif.org/occurrence/2447312746 Accessed 2026-10-19.
  12. T. Green on the Hoya finlaysonii group, Fraterna 12(4), 1999 (Internet Archive item fraternaofficial1214inte) (1999-01-01). International Hoya Association. https://archive.org/details/fraternaofficial1214inte Accessed 2026-10-19.
  13. Variations in species in the Hoya finlaysonii (Wight) complex (P. Watthanasakulcharoen, foreword by D. Baricuatro), Stemma Journal 4(2) (2022-01-01). Stemma Journal. https://stemmajournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/STEMMA42.pdf Accessed 2026-10-19.
  14. Let's hear from Hoyas about their story! (A.-M. Lemay), Fraterna volume 15, 2002 (Internet Archive item fraternaofficial1514inte) (2002-01-01). International Hoya Association. https://archive.org/details/fraternaofficial1514inte Accessed 2026-10-19.
  15. 'Noelle' (Hoya), cultivar record (2024-06-23). HoyaCultivars.org (International Cultivar Registration Authority for Hoya). https://hoyacultivars.org/noelle/ Accessed 2026-10-19.
  16. Diary of a hand pollinator (F. Baricuatro), Stemma Journal 5(2) (2023-01-01). Stemma Journal. https://stemmajournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/STEMMA52.pdf Accessed 2026-10-19.

Published by Rytas Dirse, Solo Founder & AI Architect

Built with AI, held to quality gates. US sources, US brands, facts only.

How this page was made

Digital Towns uses AI assistance to research and write its guides, and every page is only as good as the sources it cites. Our goal is the most accurate, useful local information possible.

This page was fact-checked twice before publishing.

If you see an error, or anything you can show is false, tell us right away and we will take a third look.

Report an error
Quote or describe the part that's wrong.
Explain what's actually true.
Only if you'd like a reply. Never shown publicly.

How we fact-check