Short answer
Ctenanthe and the calatheas (now Goeppertia) are separate genera of Marantaceae. Ctenanthe can form leafy, branching stems, rolls its young leaves in alternating directions, and has a short wide flower tube, two outer staminodes and one ovule [1][4]. Goeppertia is a stemless clump with a cone-like flower head, one outer staminode and three ovules [1][3]. Ctenanthe setosa survives 40 to 49 days without water in experiments, helped by water-storing cells under its upper epidermis [12].
Why are Ctenanthe plants sold as calatheas?
Because the leaves look alike and calathea is the better-known name. A Ctenanthe carries the same pulvinus (the motor joint at the top of the leaf stalk), the same nightly leaf raising and often the same silver-banded or purple-backed blades as a calathea. Retail labels follow the look. The grey-leaved 'Amagris' is patented as a Ctenanthe [6] but widely sold as Calathea Amagris; the Royal Horticultural Society's plant database files 'Greystar' only as Calathea 'Greystar', with no species given [13]; and 'Golden Mosaic', a yellow-marbled plant often sold as a calathea, is listed by NC State as a cultivar of Ctenanthe lubbersiana [7].
The 2012 reclassification did not change this. Borchsenius, Suárez and Prince found the old Calathea polyphyletic and split it, keeping Calathea in a narrow sense and moving the second clade into the resurrected genus Goeppertia [5]. Ctenanthe was not part of either genus before or after; it belongs to a different lineage, the Maranta clade, alongside Maranta, Saranthe and Stromanthe [4]. A plant sold as calathea that turns out to be a Ctenanthe is therefore not a naming update but a misidentification.
How do Ctenanthe and calathea differ, trait by trait?
The table puts the two side by side, using Goeppertia for the calathea of the trade. The genus descriptions come from Kew's Neotropikey account of the family, Roger Spencer's Horticultural Flora of South-eastern Australia, and the Maranta clade comparison of Luna and colleagues.
| Character | Ctenanthe | Calathea (Goeppertia) |
|---|---|---|
| Shoot | Rosulate (ground rosette) or caulescent (leafy stem) [4]; branched aerial shoots in C. lubbersiana [7] | Clump-forming; leaves mostly basal [3] |
| Young leaves | Antitropic: rolled in opposite directions on opposite sides of the stem [1] | Not listed as antitropic; the genus is separated on floral traits [1] |
| Leaf stalks | Often long and thin; short on flowering shoots [2] | Each leaf on its own stalk from the rhizome [3] |
| Flower head | Spikes with closely overlapping persistent bracts, flowers usually on one side [2] | Compact, cone-like (strobiliform) [1] |
| Floral tube | Very short and wide [1] | Long and narrow [1] |
| Outer staminodes | Two, slightly unequal [1] | One, larger than the petals [3] |
| Bracteole | Present [4] | Not a Maranta-clade character |
| Ovary | One chamber, one ovule [2] | Three chambers, three ovules; three-seeded capsule [3] |
A staminode is a sterile stamen turned petal-like, and in this family the outer staminodes are the showy parts of the flower, so their number can be counted with the naked eye. A bracteole is a small extra bract beside each pair of flowers. Luna and colleagues key Ctenanthe out from Maranta by exactly these: bracteole present, corolla tube as long as wide and no longer than the sepals [4].
How can you tell them apart without flowers?
Look for a stem first. A Goeppertia is a fountain of leaf stalks from soil level. Many Ctenanthe hold their leaves on jointed aerial stems: NC State describes Ctenanthe lubbersiana with stems that resemble bamboo canes and gives as quick identification hints stems above ground, branched [7]. A plant with fans of leaves at the tips of cane-like stems is not a calathea.
Then look at the leaf rolling. Hold a shoot and compare the two halves of successive blades. In Ctenanthe the leaves are antitropic, so the wider half switches sides from one leaf to the next, a character Neotropikey lists first among its useful tips for the genus [1]. Neotropikey gives no such leaf character for Calathea; every one of its tips for that genus is floral [1].
Leaf colour helps within the trade range but not as a rule. Luna and colleagues note that one group of Ctenanthe, including C. setosa, C. burle-marxii and C. kummeriana, shares discolorous leaves, generally greyish above and green or purple beneath [4]. That grey cast, with dark green bands along the lateral veins, is the look of 'Amagris' and 'Grey Star', and is uncommon among the calatheas usually sold beside them.
Is Ctenanthe really tougher than calathea?
For Ctenanthe setosa there is laboratory evidence, and it is striking. Turkish and Hungarian plant physiologists use it as a model for drought because its leaves roll slowly, over 30 to 40 days, as water runs out [11]. A 2025 study describes C. setosa as an ornamental plant that can tolerate prolonged drought periods of 40 and 49 days of water withdrawal, and recovered leaf thickness after re-watering [12]. Leaf rolling cuts the exposed surface and water loss, and Nar and colleagues found that it protects the photosystem II machinery of photosynthesis from damage during drought; leaves forced open lost more function than rolled ones [11].
The anatomy explains the reserve. Under the upper epidermis of C. setosa the 2025 study found huge hypodermal cells at the adaxial side, a layer of large cells of the kind associated with water storage in succulent plants, and that layer thinned as drought went on [12]. The native habitat fits: Flora e Funga do Brasil records C. setosa in Floresta Estacional Semidecidual, seasonal semideciduous forest with a dry season, as well as in rain forest [9].
Most calatheas offer nothing comparable. NC State describes the leaves of Goeppertia makoyana as papery thin [14], with little tissue to hold water. Two cautions apply. The drought work covers one species; Ctenanthe oppenheimiana is recorded only from Floresta Ombrófila, evergreen rain forest, in Espírito Santo, Rio de Janeiro and Santa Catarina [10]. And surviving 40 days dry in an experiment is not thriving: rolled leaves are a plant shutting down.
Which plants sold as calathea are Ctenanthe?
'Amagris'. US Plant Patent PP14641 describes a naturally occurring whole-plant mutation found in Beervelde-Lochristi, Belgium, in June 2000 within a population of the selection known as burle-marxii, classified in the patent under Ctenanthe oppenheimiana [6]. Its distinguishing traits are a compact habit, a narrow leaf, an upper leaf surface grayed green with dark green margins and venation, and a grayed purple underside [6]. One registry point needs flagging: IPNI records Ctenanthe burle-marxii H.Kenn., published in 1982, as a species in its own right [15], so the patent's placement of the burle-marxii selection under oppenheimiana does not match current taxonomy.
'Golden Mosaic' and 'Brazilian Snow'. NC State lists both under Ctenanthe lubbersiana, with dark green leaves irregularly striped bright yellowish-green or light yellow-green [7].
'Tricolor'. The cream-striped form with burgundy undersides, sometimes called never never plant, is listed by NC State under Ctenanthe oppenheimiana [8].
'Grey Star'. Trade sources attach this name to Ctenanthe setosa, but no primary record confirming the species was located: the RHS entry reads only Calathea 'Greystar' [13], and no plant patent or registration was found as of 2026-10-08. Its grey-topped, purple-backed leaves match the discolorous Ctenanthe group described above [4].
Does the difference change how you grow them?
In three practical ways. First, propagation: a Ctenanthe with aerial stems can be increased from stem pieces as well as by division, and NC State lists both methods for C. oppenheimiana [8], whereas a Goeppertia clump is divided at the rhizome. Second, watering rhythm: NC State advises watering C. lubbersiana when the top inch of the mix feels dry [7], while its calathea records ask for soil kept evenly moist, as for G. makoyana [14]. A Ctenanthe forgives a missed watering better, and the leaf rolling of C. setosa is a visible signal to water rather than a sign of damage [11]. Third, size: C. lubbersiana forms bushes almost 6 feet tall in its native habitat [7], so the caned species need more height than most calatheas.
What they share matters as much. Both are understorey herbs of Neotropical forest, both burn in direct sun, and NC State recommends distilled or filtered water for C. lubbersiana [7] as it does for the calatheas. The toughness of Ctenanthe is a wider margin for error, not a different kind of plant.
Frequently asked questions
Is Calathea Amagris a calathea?
No. Its US plant patent, PP14641, classifies 'Amagris' as a Ctenanthe, a whole-plant mutation of the selection known as burle-marxii found in Belgium in 2000 [6]. Calathea Amagris is a trade label, not a botanical name.
Is Grey Star a calathea or a ctenanthe?
It is traded as a form of Ctenanthe setosa, but no primary record confirming that was located. The RHS lists it only as Calathea 'Greystar' [13]. Its grey upper face and purple underside match the discolorous Ctenanthe group [4].
Is Ctenanthe more drought tolerant than calathea?
Ctenanthe setosa is: it has survived 40 to 49 days without water in experiments, aided by large water-storing hypodermal cells [12]. That result has not been shown for every Ctenanthe, and C. oppenheimiana is a rain-forest species [10].
Is Ctenanthe safe for cats and dogs?
The ASPCA has no Ctenanthe entry; the genus does not appear in its cats plant list as of 2026-10-08 [16]. ASPCA's non-toxic listing for Calathea spp. covers Calathea only and should not be read across to Ctenanthe.
Did Ctenanthe move to Goeppertia in 2012?
No. The 2012 revision split the old Calathea and resurrected Goeppertia for one of its clades [5]. Ctenanthe sits in the separate Maranta clade with Maranta and Stromanthe [4] and kept its name.