Short answer
A US plant patent protects a new plant variety discovered in cultivation and reproduced asexually, for 20 years from filing under current law [1]. Hoyas qualify because most named forms are sports, branch mutations found on nursery stock. The eight Hoya patents located from 1969 to 1978 all went to Barnell L. Cobia or his Florida company [4][5]. The next five located were granted from 2024 to 2026 [13][14][15][16][17]. Each grant also fixes the cultivar name [2].
What does a US plant patent protect, and why do hoyas qualify?
Under 35 U.S.C. 161 a plant patent goes to whoever invents or discovers and asexually reproduces a distinct and new variety of plant, including cultivated sports, mutants, hybrids and newly found seedlings, other than a tuber-propagated plant or a plant found in an uncultivated state [1]. The grant lasts 20 years from the filing date and lets the owner exclude others from asexually reproducing, selling or using the plant in the United States [1]. When it expires, the USPTO notes, the subject matter passes into the public domain [1].
Two conditions shape which hoyas get patented. First, the plant has to have been found in a cultivated state, so a wild-collected clone of a species brought in from the forest cannot be patented, however rare. Second, protection covers asexual reproduction, which for a hoya means cuttings and layering, the way every named hoya is propagated anyway. A sport (a branch whose cells carry a new mutation, often in leaf colour) suits this exactly: it appears on stock in a greenhouse and holds its character only through cuttings. The USPTO also points out that a plant derived from a sport of a patented plant is unlikely to have the same genotype and so is not covered by the original patent [1]. That is why a new sport of a patented hoya can carry its own patent, as the 2026 grant below shows.
Which hoyas did B. L. Cobia, Inc. patent?
Between 1969 and 1978 a single Winter Garden, Florida nursery turned its sport selection programme into eight patents. The table gives the dates as printed on each patent; the individual cultivar pages hold the descriptions.
| Patent | Cultivar (register name) | Filed | Granted |
|---|---|---|---|
| PP 2,950 | 'Tricolor' | 9 Jan 1968 | 9 Dec 1969 [4] |
| PP 3,008 | 'Krinkle 8' | 31 Jul 1968 | 8 Dec 1970 [5] |
| PP 3,054 | 'Mauna Loa' | 13 Mar 1969 | 10 Aug 1971 [6] |
| PP 3,105 | 'Rubra' | 16 Feb 1970 | 11 Apr 1972 [7] |
| PP 3,306 | 'Regalis' | 18 May 1971 | 20 Feb 1973 [8] |
| PP 3,307 | 'Argentea Picta' | 18 May 1971 | 20 Feb 1973 [9] |
| PP 3,310 | 'Marginalis' | 18 May 1971 | 27 Feb 1973 [10] |
| PP 4,199 | 'Krinkle 8 Variegata' | 18 Jan 1977 | 24 Jan 1978 [11] |
Every one is a sport of Hoya carnosa, and the lineage can be read straight off the documents. 'Tricolor' came out of the firm's variegated stock, 'Rubra' is described against 'Exotica', and 'Mauna Loa' arose as a bud variation on a cultivated plant of the compacta variety, as its patent puts it [6]. 'Krinkle 8' is the exception in authorship: the patent names its inventor as assignor to B. L. Cobia, Inc. [5], so the firm bought the rights rather than raising the plant. 'Krinkle 8 Variegata' names two inventors and the company as assignee [11]. All eight have long since expired. The register's entry for 'Marginalis' explains why they are hard to find: most of the firm's patents were titled simply Milkweed Plant, with numbers that do not surface in name searches [12].
Why does a patent fix a hoya's cultivar name?
The cultivated plant code treats a patent office as a statutory plant registration authority. Under Article 27.5 a cultivar name is established if it is accepted under an equivalent term in a register kept by such an authority [2], and Article 11.4 states that a name designated in a statutory register remains the accepted name even after statutory protection lapses [2]. A registration authority may not reject a name that a statutory authority has accepted [2]. In practice the variety denomination printed in the patent becomes the cultivar epithet for good.
This rescues names that would otherwise fail. 'Rubra' and 'Argentea Picta' are wholly Latin epithets published after 1958, a form the code normally refuses, but the register accepts them because the patents carried them [3][12]. The same rule makes the modern code-form names legitimate: an epithet such as 'AMZ001' or 'G4Y0002' is a permitted code of letters and numerals [2], and the patent is its establishing publication. A patent can also mislead. The register searched for a Plant Patent 3,204 cited in a 1978 sales insert for PINK SILVER hoyas [19], but US Plant Patent 3,204, granted in 1972, is for a kalanchoe [18]. The number on that advertisement cannot be a Hoya patent; the Hoya trade designations page covers the selling name itself.
Which hoyas have been patented since 2024?
This survey located no Hoya plant patent granted between 1978 and 2024; neither the register nor the patents cited here mention one, although a full USPTO classification search could not be run for this page. Then five arrived in two years, from three applicants on three continents.
| Patent | Denomination and species | Origin stated in the patent |
|---|---|---|
| PP 35,955 | 'JAD037', H. ilagiorum | Whole-plant mutation in unpatented stock, Chuzhou, China, May 2020 [13] |
| PP 36,085 | 'Jingfeng Variegata', H. commutata | Spontaneous mutation in unnamed stock, Chuzhou, September 2019 [14] |
| PP 36,350 | 'AMZ001', H. elliptica | Branch mutation, Southwest Ranches, Florida, March 2022 [15] |
| PP 36,356 | 'Grey Fairy', H. carnosa x serpens | Branch mutation on 'Mathilde', Chuzhou, April 2021 [16] |
| PP 37,411 | 'G4Y0002', H. carnosa | Branch mutation among 'Tri-Color' plants, Bogor, Indonesia, January 2022 [17] |
Three of the five, 'JAD037', 'Jingfeng Variegata' and 'Grey Fairy', were filed on the same day, 25 September 2023, by Anhui Jadeite Garden Co., Ltd [13][14][16]. 'JAD037' was granted on 2 July 2024 [13], 'Jingfeng Variegata' on 27 August 2024 [14], and 'AMZ001' and 'Grey Fairy' both on 31 December 2024 [15][16]. 'G4Y0002', assigned to Grow 4 You B.V., was granted on 5 May 2026 and claims priority from a European Community Plant Variety Rights application filed on 1 March 2024 [17]. Its patent names the parent stock as Hoya carnosa 'Tri-Color' and cites Plant Patent 2,950 [17], so the newest Hoya patent descends directly from the oldest.
Both host species of the Chinese grants are recent names, and both are accepted in Kew's checklist: Hoya ilagiorum Kloppenb., Siar & Cajano, published in 2011 [20], and Hoya commutata M.G.Gilbert & P.T.Li, published in 1995 [21].
How do the patents line up with the Hoya register?
The register for Hoya has entries for 'AMZ001' and 'Grey Fairy', both accepted on the strength of their patents [3]. A search of HoyaCultivars.org on 2026-10-09 returned nothing for 'JAD037', 'Jingfeng' or 'G4Y0002' [22], so those three denominations are established by statute but not yet listed on the checklist. The patents also use comparison names the register does not hold: the 'JAD037' patent compares the plant with Hoya 'Amore Variegata' [13], and the 'Jingfeng Variegata' patent compares it with Hoya 'Krinkle Kurl' [14]. A search for Amore on the register likewise returned nothing [22]. Those comparison names are a patent attorney's labels for commercial stock, not checked cultivar names, and should not be copied onto tags as if a patent had validated them.
The 'G4Y0002' patent writes its parent as 'Tri-Color' [17], the spelling Cobia preferred in his own print material; the register treats 'Tri-Color' as a later synonym of the accepted 'Tricolor' [3]. Its description of juvenile foliage, brown centres broadly margined in red to greyed purple that read as pink, then maturing to green with a pale yellow edge [17], fits a further edge-variegated step in the same lineage that runs from 'Variegata' through 'Tricolor'.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to propagate a patented hoya?
Not without permission while the patent is in force: a US plant patent lets the owner exclude others from asexually reproducing, selling or using the plant for 20 years from filing [1]. The 1969 to 1978 Cobia patents have all expired [3].
Which was the first hoya plant patent?
US Plant Patent 2,950, granted on 9 December 1969 for the Hoya carnosa now called 'Tricolor', filed by Barnell L. Cobia of Winter Garden, Florida in January 1968 [4].
Is 'Grey Fairy' patented?
Yes. US Plant Patent 36,356, granted on 31 December 2024, covers 'Grey Fairy', a branch mutation found on Hoya carnosa x serpens 'Mathilde' in a nursery in Chuzhou, China, in April 2021 [16].
Can a wild hoya species be patented?
No. The plant patent statute excludes a plant found in an uncultivated state [1]. A sport or seedling found in cultivation can qualify, which is why every Hoya patent located here covers a mutation or selection raised in a nursery.
Does an expired patent change the cultivar name?
No. Under the cultivated plant code a name designated in a statutory register remains the accepted name even after protection lapses [2], so 'Rubra' and 'Regalis' keep their patent names.