Short answer
A trade designation is a selling name used in place of, or beside, a plant's accepted cultivar name; the cultivated plant code does not regulate it and never treats it as a synonym [1]. Most famous hoya label names are of this kind. KRIMSON QUEEN was a registered trademark of B. L. Cobia, Inc., expired in 2002 [2], used for Hoya carnosa 'Tricolor' [3]. KRIMSON PRINCESS sold 'Rubra' [4], HINDU ROPE several Compacta sports [5], and PINK SILVER is not the cultivar 'Silver Pink' [9].
What separates a trade designation from a cultivar name?
The International Code of Nomenclature for Cultivated Plants (ICNCP, ninth edition, 2016) governs cultivar names, the epithets written in single quotes after a botanical name, as in Hoya carnosa 'Tricolor'. Article 13 defines the other thing found on labels: a trade designation is not a name regulated under the Code but a device that has been used for marketing a cultivar, Group or grex in place of, or in addition to, its accepted name [1]. Article 13.2 adds that a trade designation is not to be cited as a synonym [1]. A synonym is itself a name, only not the accepted one; a trade designation has no nomenclatural standing at all.
Trademarks are the strictest case. Principle 6 of the Code states that trademarks are the intellectual property of an individual or corporate body, not freely available for anyone to use, and so cannot be treated as names [1]. Article 17 then sets the presentation rules: a trade designation may not be placed inside the single quotes reserved for cultivar epithets, it must be accompanied by the accepted name when cited, and it must look typographically different, usually in small capitals [1]. That is why the hoya register writes these marks in capitals, and why Hoya carnosa 'Krimson Queen' with quotes is an error of form as well as of fact. The Code also lets a registration authority record trademarks used for cultivars, provided they are never given nomenclatural status [1].
Which hoya selling names began as trademarks?
Almost all the classic ones came out of one Florida nursery, B. L. Cobia, Inc. of Winter Garden, which patented its sports as legal varieties and sold them under registered marks from the late 1960s. The table matches each mark to the cultivar the register says it was meant to sell; every row has its own cultivar page.
| Trade designation | Cultivar it marketed | Status recorded |
|---|---|---|
| KRIMSON QUEEN | H. carnosa 'Tricolor' | US registration 905698, 1971; expired 2002 [2][3] |
| KRIMSON PRINCESS | H. carnosa 'Rubra' | Trademarked 1969 to 2002 [4] |
| HINDU ROPE | 'Compacta', 'Marginalis', 'Regalis' | Former trademark applied to several clones [5][6] |
| LURA-LEI and LIVING-LEI | H. carnosa 'Mauna Loa' | Expired 2010 [7] |
| SILVER PRINCESS | H. carnosa 'Argentea Picta' | Registered 1971, expired 2002 [8] |
| PINK SILVER | Undetermined H. pubicalyx selection, not 'Silver Pink' | Trade designation, invalid as a cultivar name [9] |
The United States Patent and Trademark Office record for KRIMSON QUEEN gives a filing date of 4 September 1969, registration on 12 January 1971, and B. L. Cobia, Inc. as owner [2]. The goods listed are tropical house plants, and the first use in commerce is given as 13 January 1967 [2], a year before the patent application for 'Tricolor' was filed in January 1968 (the details are on the Hoya plant patents page). The selling name, in other words, was on the market before the plant had a published name. The register's own note for SILVER PRINCESS records that the mark could not be found in the USPTO system [8], so for that one the dates rest on secondary sources.
How did KRIMSON QUEEN stop meaning one plant?
By the route the Code itself warns about. A note to Article 8 cautions that anyone marketing a cultivar under a trademark should be aware of the risk of the trademark becoming generic unless an accepted name is also given [1]. Wherever a pot carried the mark without the epithet, the mark was the only word a buyer could copy onto the next label. The registry entry for 'Tricolor' states that KRIMSON QUEEN was widely applied, during Cobia's use and for decades afterwards, to many clones of variegated Hoya carnosa, and that hoyas labelled only KRIMSON QUEEN cannot be assumed to be 'Tricolor' [3]. The registration lapsed when it was not renewed at its ten-year expiry [3]; the USPTO status page lists it as expired on 19 January 2002 after a first renewal in 1991 [2].
KRIMSON PRINCESS followed the same path for inner-variegated plants. The register records that older centre-variegated cultivars such as 'Picta' and 'Exotica' became hard to find because they were all labelled with Cobia's expired mark for 'Rubra', written as though it were a cultivar name [4]. The mechanism is botanical as much as commercial: 'Tricolor' and 'Rubra' are variegated sports of one lineage, and that lineage has thrown many similar edge- and centre-variegated branches, so a mark that once named one clone ended up covering a whole family of look-alike sports. The USPTO record adds one detail rarely repeated: it disclaims any rights in the word KRIMSON apart from the full mark [2]. The Krimson Queen versus Krimson Princess comparison covers how the two plants differ in the hand.
Is Hindu rope a common name or a trademark?
It began as a trademark. The register's entry for 'Marginalis' records HINDU ROPE as a former Cobia trademark applied to multiple cultivars, including 'Marginalis', 'Regalis' and the Hoya carnosa 'Compacta' the firm bought and distributed [5]. The entry for 'Regalis' adds that the mark was applied to all hoyas of this Group grown by Cobia, and that the company also used HINDU ROPE NEW in marketing [6]. A 1978 distributor insert placed KRIMSON PRINCESS, HINDU ROPE and PINK SILVER in capitals above the botanical names in italics, which the registrar cites as the evidence that these were selling names in the Article 13 sense [9].
Since then the phrase has drifted into general use for any rope hoya, the plants with folded, contorted leaves now gathered in the Hoya carnosa Compacta Group. That drift is exactly the generic fate described above, and it is why a tag reading only Hindu rope says nothing about which Compacta clone is in the pot: plain green 'Compacta', cream-edged 'Marginalis', red-flushed 'Regalis' and centre-variegated 'Mauna Loa' all wear it. The Hindu rope identification page separates them by leaf pattern.
Which hoya selling names were never trademarks?
Not every trade designation is a registered mark. The register lists 'Ripple' as an unestablished trade designation, invalid for use as a cultivar name or synonym, usually used in place of Hoya carnosa 'Krinkle 8' [11]. For H. incrassata 'Eclipse', established in a 2006 printed mail-order catalogue, the register notes that the plant is sometimes mislabelled with the invalid trade designation 'Albomarginata' [13]. That case shows a second reason a label name fails: an epithet entirely in Latin form published after 1958 cannot be established as a cultivar name unless a statutory registration carries it [1].
Some selling names are attached deliberately by the originator. The patented H. elliptica 'AMZ001' is also labelled EMMA, which the register records as a personal trade designation and not a cultivar epithet [12]. Under Article 17 the correct form is H. elliptica EMMA ('AMZ001'), with the code epithet as the name and the word in capitals as the selling label [1]. PINK SILVER is the unresolved case. The register treats it as a trade designation used by Cobia for a selected H. pubicalyx sport whose identity is pending determination, and states that it is not equivalent to the accepted cultivar 'Silver Pink' [9][10], a selection the register traces to a speckled sport documented under a USDA accession number [10].
How should a hoya label with a trade name be read?
Treat any word in capitals, any trademark symbol and any name the register files as a trade designation as a pointer, not an identity. The Code's own pattern puts the selling name in small capitals beside the cultivar epithet in quotes, as in Hoya carnosa KRIMSON PRINCESS ('Rubra') [1]. A label in that form tells a buyer both the marketing name and the plant. A label with the mark alone carries only the marketing history, and for the Cobia marks that history covers several clones [3][4].
- If the tag gives a quoted epithet, check it against the Hoya cultivar register.
- If it gives only a mark such as KRIMSON QUEEN or HINDU ROPE, identify the plant by leaf pattern before passing it on under a cultivar name [3][5].
- Do not convert a mark into an epithet by adding quotes; under Article 13.2 it can never become a synonym [1].
The hoya varieties guide explains the other label layers, from species and Groups to the (v) mark for variegated plants.
Frequently asked questions
Is Krimson Queen a hoya cultivar?
No. KRIMSON QUEEN was a US trademark of B. L. Cobia, Inc., registered in 1971 and expired in 2002 [2]. It was used to sell Hoya carnosa 'Tricolor', but the register warns that plants labelled only Krimson Queen cannot be assumed to be 'Tricolor' [3].
What cultivar is Krimson Princess?
KRIMSON PRINCESS was Cobia's trademark for Hoya carnosa 'Rubra', held from 1969 to 2002 [4]. It later spread to other centre-variegated carnosa clones, so the label alone does not prove the plant is 'Rubra' [4].
Are Pink Silver and Silver Pink the same hoya?
Not according to the register. 'Silver Pink' is the accepted cultivar name for a Hoya pubicalyx selection [10]; PINK SILVER is a trade designation used by Cobia for a sport whose identity is still undetermined, and it is not equivalent to 'Silver Pink' [9].
Can a trade designation become a cultivar name later?
No. The cultivated plant code states that a trade designation is not a name and is not to be cited as a synonym [1]. The reverse can happen: an established name that becomes a synonym may also be used as a trade designation [1].
Who owned the Hindu Rope trademark?
The register records HINDU ROPE as a former trademark of B. L. Cobia, Inc., applied to 'Compacta', 'Marginalis' and 'Regalis' [5][6]. It now circulates as a general name for rope hoyas, which is why it identifies no single cultivar.