Short answer
Hoya stems root well in plain water: the RHS gives two to three weeks for cuttings stood in a glass [1]. The genus already climbs by adventitious roots [6], so the stem is primed to root. Roots grown in water are not the same organ as roots grown in a mix: in maize, outer barrier layers and branching develop differently in liquid culture than in solid media [2] [3]. Pot up once there are plenty of roots [1], into an aerated mix [5].
Why does a hoya cutting root in plain water?
Most of the work is done before the cutting ever reaches the glass. The Flora of China describes Hoya as epiphytic or epilithic subshrubs and lianas that often climb by adventitious roots [6], roots that arise from the stem rather than from a seedling's first root. Martin, Hsu and Lin (2009) describe wild Hoya carnosa in a Taiwanese rainforest as large epiphytic vines whose long, crawling shoots climb from the base of the host tree to the canopy [7]. A stem that roots onto wet bark along its whole length does not need soil to start roots.
Cutting the stem sets the process going. Druege and colleagues (2019) review the physiology across many crops: the wound and the loss of the parent's root system together trigger root formation, and auxin moving down from the leaves accumulates above the cut [4]. The first stage, the induction phase, is an anatomical lag phase with no visible cell changes [4]. In a jar this is the week or two when nothing seems to happen. The Royal Horticultural Society's hoya guide puts the whole sequence at two or three weeks for cuttings taken in spring or early summer [1].
Water also removes two failure points of a mix: the cutting cannot dry out, and the grower can watch the nodes. Hoya carnosa runs crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), fixing carbon dioxide at night [8], so its leaves lose relatively little water during the day even before roots exist; water rooting suits it for convenience more than necessity.
Are roots grown in water different from roots grown in a mix?
Yes, though nobody has sectioned hoya roots to show it directly; the best evidence comes from model crops. The relevant tissue is the exodermis, the layer of cells just inside the root's skin. When it matures it lays down Casparian bands (waterproof strips in the cell walls) and suberin lamellae (fatty sheets lining the cells). Hose and colleagues (2001) describe the exodermis as a barrier of variable resistance to water and solutes, whose extent and rate of formation depend on conditions such as drought, anoxia and salinity [3]. As those barriers form, the root's permeability to water and solutes is reduced [3].
Tylová and colleagues (2017) grew maize in aerated and stagnant liquid culture, in soil, flooded soil and a sand and perlite mix, and stained the roots [2]. In contrast to plants in hydroponics, plants in the solid media had easily detectable exodermal Casparian bands, even in very short young side roots [2]. Soil-grown roots also branched far more, producing many second- and third-order laterals that aerated hydroponics did not [2].
If hoya roots follow the same rules, and no study has yet checked, a cutting rooted in a jar carries a sparsely branched system without the outer barrier that slows water loss in a drying medium. Moved into bark and perlite, it meets air pockets and wet-dry cycles it was not built for. The pause many growers report after potting a water-rooted Hoya, while new roots form from the same nodes, fits that explanation, but it is an inference from maize, not a measured hoya result.
Why do some hoya cuttings sit in water and never root?
Oxygen is the first suspect. Roots need it to grow, and still water holds little and loses it as microbes feed on the cut surface. In the maize study, stagnant hydroponics with oxygen saturation under 20% produced very short primary roots, as did flooded soil [2]. A hoya node submerged in a tall jar of old water is in the same position. Shallow water that covers the node and no more, changed every few days, keeps oxygen near the tissue that is trying to root.
The second is what is under water. Only nodes root readily; the University of Kentucky propagation guide notes that roots develop faster at nodal areas with active meristematic cells [9]. A cutting with only internode below the waterline, or a leaf without a node, may form callus and a few roots but has no axillary bud to grow on, as explained on the hoya leaf-cuttings page. Leaves left under water soften and rot, fouling the jar for the stem.
The third is the stem itself. In the controlled Hoya carnosa trial from Paraguay, the researchers discarded the last 1 to 2 cm of each shoot because the terminal portion is excessively succulent and prone to wilting [5]. Soft tips are also the parts most likely to rot in water. Firmer wood from the previous year's growth, as the RHS recommends [1], roots more reliably.
When should a water-rooted hoya move to a mix, and into what?
The RHS advice is to pot hoya cuttings up once they have plenty of roots [1]. A cluster of short roots, rather than a single long one, is the better sign, because branching is exactly what water-grown roots tend to lack [2]. Waiting for one root to grow very long only enlarges the part of the system that is poorly adapted to the pot.
The medium should be aerated. In the Paraguayan trial of eight media for H. carnosa cuttings, rooting percentage barely varied, but root length and number did, and the authors concluded that the best substrates combined good aeration with moderate moisture retention [5]. Phenolic foam, with limited water retention, produced the shortest roots [5]. An airy bark, perlite and peat or coir blend matches that finding, and matches where wild Hoya carnosa lives: Kew's Plants of the World Online lists it as a climbing epiphyte or lithophyte [10], rooted on bark and rock that drain in hours.
Keep the newly potted cutting more evenly moist for its first few weeks than an established hoya, so that the water roots are not stranded while new ones form, then return to letting the mix dry between waterings. Some growers skip the problem by moving cuttings into semi-hydroponic media, covered on the hoya semi-hydro page. Whatever the route, root rot after potting, covered on the hoya root-rot page, usually starts with a water-rooted cutting sunk into a dense, wet mix.
Can a hoya just stay in water?
It can survive for a long time, but it is a holding pattern, not a culture. A jar has no nutrients, little oxygen and constant wetness, while the plant's natural root environment is bark and rock that alternate between wet and dry. Under drought, Hoya carnosa shifts into CAM-idling, with complete or almost complete stomatal closure, and held that state for at least eight weeks in a laboratory study before recovering within a week of rewatering [8]. That tolerance means a potted hoya copes far better with a slightly dry mix than with permanent saturation, which is the opposite of what a jar provides.
Frequently asked questions
How long do hoya cuttings take to root in water?
The RHS gives two or three weeks for hoya cuttings stood in a glass of water in spring or early summer [1]. The first week or two is the induction phase, when cells are reprogramming but nothing is visible [4], so a firm, green cutting with no roots yet is usually still working.
Why is my hoya cutting not rooting in water?
Check three things: that a node, not just bare internode, is under water [9]; that the water is shallow and fresh, since stagnant, oxygen-poor water stunts roots [2]; and that the cutting is firm wood rather than a soft tip, which tends to wilt and rot [5].
Should I add rooting hormone to the water?
It is not needed. Wild Hoya species rooted from stem cuttings without hormone in a trial in Brunei [11], and Hoya carnosa forms adventitious roots readily under a wide range of conditions [5]. Hormone mainly raised root numbers, not whether cuttings rooted [11].
Do water roots die when a hoya is potted up?
Some may. In maize, roots grown in liquid culture lacked the exodermal barriers and branching seen in soil-grown roots [2], and those barriers govern water flow [3]. Hoya roots have not been studied this way, but a short pause while mix-adapted roots form is common.