Short answer
The prayer plant is Maranta leuconeura, a low, branching plant native to central and eastern Brazil [2]. The peacock plant is Goeppertia makoyana, formerly Calathea makoyana, an upright clump from Espírito Santo [1]. Both came to Europe through the Jacob-Makoy nursery of Liège [3][4]. The peacock plant's leaf has translucent windows where the leaf tissue is missing between the veins [3], while the prayer plant's leaf is velvety with whitish veins [4]. ASPCA's Peacock Plant entry is a different plant entirely [9].
Which plant is the peacock plant?
In the houseplant trade, peacock plant means Goeppertia makoyana (É.Morren) Borchs. & S.Suárez, which Kew's Plants of the World Online accepts with the combination published in Systematic Botany in 2012 [1]. Its basionym (the original name on which later combinations rest) is Calathea makoyana É.Morren of 1872, and it also passed through Maranta makoyana (É.Morren) T.Moore & Mast. in 1873 [1]. NC State Extension lists brain plant, cathedral windows, peacock calathea and peacock plant as its common names [7]. So the peacock plant was once filed in Maranta, which is part of why buyers still meet it next to the prayer plant.
One trap matters for pet owners. The ASPCA database entry titled Peacock Plant is not this species: it gives the additional names peacock ginger and Kaempferia, the scientific name Kaempferia, and the family Zingiberaceae, the gingers [9]. Searching the ASPCA site for peacock plant therefore returns a ginger, not a member of Marantaceae.
Where do Maranta leuconeura and Goeppertia makoyana come from?
POWO gives the native range of Goeppertia makoyana as Brazil (Espírito Santo), a perennial of the wet tropical biome [1], and of Maranta leuconeura as central and eastern Brazil, a subshrub of the same biome [2]. The prayer plant therefore has the wider range; the peacock plant is recorded from one coastal state of the Atlantic Forest region.
The protologue (original publication) of the peacock plant tells a slightly different story. Édouard Morren wrote in 1872 that Jacob-Makoy had received it from Emil Wittig, a gardener in Rio de Janeiro, who had it from a landowner in the province of Minas Gerais [3]; it grew on his plantation of Cachoeira do Cravo, deep in a grove beside a stream [3]. That is a secondhand locality, not a herbarium collection, and Kew's range does not include Minas Gerais. Morren named the plant for the Makoy firm, to keep in the annals of science the services the house rendered to botany and horticulture [3]. Two years later the same nursery received the prayer plant in a large consignment of Brazilian plants, and Morren described it as new [4].
How do the two plants compare, side by side?
| Trait | Prayer plant, Maranta leuconeura | Peacock plant, Goeppertia makoyana |
|---|---|---|
| Native range (POWO) | Central and eastern Brazil [2] | Espírito Santo, Brazil [1] |
| Habit | Low to prostrate, branched [5] | Erect leaves from a rhizome, in clumps [3] |
| Height | Low, spreading sideways [8] | Leaves seen to 60 cm tall in 1872 [3] |
| Leaf surface | Somewhat velvety, whitish secondary veins [4] | Glossy and papery thin, with translucent panels [3][7] |
| Underside | Grey-green to purple-green [8] | Red-violet, repeating the upper pattern [3][7] |
| Flower cluster | Narrow spike with two bracts [5] | Paired white flowers with purple lobes, spirally arranged green bracts [7] |
| Night movement | Blades flat by day, near vertical at night [8] | First leaves horizontal, later leaves erect [3] |
The flower row carries the genus difference. A bract is the leaf-like scale that encloses a pair of flowers; in Maranta leuconeura the flowering spike carries only two of them [5], while the calathea type has many bracts set in a spiral [6][7]. Few houseplants flower, so habit is the working test: the prayer plant branches and spreads, the peacock plant sends each leaf straight up from the soil on a long, slender petiole (leaf stalk) [7].
Why does a peacock plant leaf look like stained glass?
Morren answered this in his 1872 description. Along the midrib of Goeppertia makoyana run alternating long and short bands of dark green, purple-red beneath. Between them the leaf is colourless and translucent, marked only by fine green veins, because the parenchyma (the soft green tissue that fills a leaf between its veins) develops only in the opaque bands and is absent from the clear areas, where the tissue is reduced to veins [3]. He compared the effect to a fern frond, a Polypodium for example, laid against a lace background [3]. The trade name cathedral windows describes exactly that.
The prayer plant's leaf is built the other way. Morren's diagnosis of Maranta leuconeura separates it from its relatives by a somewhat velvety leaf and whitish secondary veins [4]: the pattern lies in pigment and surface, over a leaf that is green throughout. A leaf with clear panels has less living tissue per square centimetre and a thinner blade, which NC State describes as papery thin [7]. The likely consequence, an inference from the anatomy rather than a measured result, is that the peacock plant's thin, partly empty blade has less tissue to hold water between the veins, so dry air would be expected to show at its edges sooner than on the prayer plant.
How does each plant's habit change its care?
The prayer plant's branching stems decide how it is used. NC State notes that it is often grown in hanging baskets and as ground cover in interior plantings [8]; the stems spill over a pot edge and root where they touch soil, so the plant suits a wide, shallow container and propagates from stem pieces as well as by division. The peacock plant has no such stems. Its leaves rise from a rhizome, and new leaves emerge rolled, showing their pinkish-red undersides [7], so a peacock plant is divided at the rhizome and needs depth for the clump rather than width for runners.
Night movement also differs in degree. In Maranta leuconeura the leaves are held parallel to the ground by day and move to a perpendicular prayer position at night [8], a large and easily read signal. Morren noted that the first leaves of a young peacock plant spread horizontally while later, larger leaves stand erect [3], so most of an established clump stands upright day and night. On a peacock plant, condition shows first in the leaf edges and in how cleanly each rolled new leaf opens.
Light and humidity needs, by contrast, are shared, and they follow from the habitat Morren reported: a shaded grove beside a stream. NC State describes Goeppertia makoyana as thriving where it is warm, shaded and humid [7], and warns that too much sun bleaches the leaf colours of Maranta leuconeura, which needs high humidity [8]. Both are understorey plants whose patterns fade in direct sun, so the same bright, indirect position suits either one.
Is either plant toxic to cats or dogs?
The ASPCA lists Calathea spp. as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses [10], and the peacock plant falls under that genus name in its database. Its Prayer Plant entry, labelled Calathea insignis but listing Maranta and Peacock Plant among its alternative names, is also listed as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses [11]. Neither of those records uses the names Goeppertia makoyana or Maranta leuconeura, and the record titled Peacock Plant describes Kaempferia, a ginger [9]. The non-toxic listing for Kaempferia says nothing about the Marantaceae peacock plant.
Frequently asked questions
Is the peacock plant a prayer plant?
Not botanically. The peacock plant is Goeppertia makoyana and the prayer plant is Maranta leuconeura; both are Marantaceae [1][2]. The peacock plant was once called Maranta makoyana, which explains the overlap in trade names [1].
How do I tell a prayer plant from a peacock plant?
The prayer plant is low and branching, with velvety leaves and whitish veins [4][5]. The peacock plant holds each leaf upright on a long slender petiole, and its thin leaves have translucent panels between dark green bands [3][7].
Is the ASPCA Peacock Plant the same as Calathea makoyana?
No. The ASPCA entry titled Peacock Plant is Kaempferia, a member of the ginger family Zingiberaceae [9]. For the Marantaceae peacock plant, the relevant ASPCA record is Calathea spp., listed as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses [10].
Why is Goeppertia makoyana called cathedral windows?
Between its dark green bands the leaf lacks the green parenchyma tissue, leaving clear panels crossed only by fine veins [3]. Backlit, the leaf looks like leaded glass, the source of the name recorded by NC State [7].






