Short answer
Both are variegated forms of Stromanthe thalia, the plant sold as Stromanthe sanguinea [1][6]. NC State Extension describes Triostar as green variegated with white, cream and pink, with pink to burgundy undersides that are themselves pink-variegated, and Magic Star as green with creamy white variegation and maroon undersides [1]. The practical test is pink on the upper face. Neither name is backed by a patent or registration record located for this page [4][5], and care is identical.
What are Triostar and Magic Star?
Both are selections of one species. North Carolina State Extension lists 'Magic Star' and 'Triostar' as the cultivars of Stromanthe thalia [1], and Kew's Plants of the World Online treats Stromanthe sanguinea, the name on most labels, as a synonym of Stromanthe thalia [6]. Everything botanical about the species, its Brazilian Atlantic Forest origin, its leaf movement and its flowers, applies to both.
Triostar has the better paper trail. UF/IFAS Extension describes it under Stromanthe sanguinea 'Triostar', notes that it is sometimes called 'Tricolor', and explains that both names come from the leaf colours [2]. The Nassau County extension office records that it was named a 2008 Florida Plant of the Year by the Florida Nursery, Growers and Landscape Association [3]. NC State adds that it is sold under several names, including 'Tristar', 'Tricolor' and 'Triostar' [1].
Magic Star has almost none. Apart from the NC State cultivar list [1], no patent, registration or breeder record for a Stromanthe called Magic Star was located as of 2026-10-08. The only patented variegated Stromanthe thalia found is 'Valmic', U.S. Plant Patent PP15475, which uses neither trade name [4]. No International Cultivar Registration Authority is listed for Stromanthe on the ISHS list [5], so neither name can have been formally registered. The registry therefore treats both as trade names in use; see the Magic Star record.
How do the two compare side by side?
The table brings together the published descriptions of Triostar, Magic Star and the patented 'Valmic'. An entry of none located means no source found for this page gives that trait.
| Trait | Triostar | Magic Star | 'Valmic' (PP15475) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upper leaf surface | Green variegated with white, cream and pink [1]; white and green [2] | Green with creamy white variegation [1] | Green and creamy white [4] |
| Lower leaf surface | Solid pink to burgundy with pink variegations [1]; brilliant reddish-pink [2] | Maroon [1] | Purple, with random spots, streaks and blotches [4] |
| Size | 2 to 3 ft tall, 1 to 2 ft wide at maturity [2] | None located | About 80 cm tall, 105 cm wide at 20 weeks [4] |
| Name record | Florida Plant of the Year 2008 [3]; no patent located | Extension cultivar list only [1] | U.S. Plant Patent, 2005 [4] |
| Origin documented | None located | None located | Whole-plant mutation of 'Stripestar', found 1999 in the Netherlands [4] |
Read across the rows, the split is clear. Triostar is defined by pink in the variegation on both faces. Magic Star is defined by cream without pink above and a dark maroon underside. The patent wording for 'Valmic', green and creamy white leaves with purple lower surfaces [4], fits the Magic Star description at least as well as the Triostar one, so leaf colour alone cannot assign either trade name to the patented clone.
Why is one pink and the other cream?
Two pigment systems are involved. The cream or white patches are tissue without working chloroplasts; in chimeric ornamentals such albino tissue has been traced to mutations that disable plastid genes [9]. The red and pink come from anthocyanins, by far the most common red pigments of flowering plants [10]. Stromanthe thalia already makes them in the lower leaf surface: Flora do Brasil records the blade as discolorous, glossy green above and purple beneath [7].
Pink on the upper face appears where cells that lack chlorophyll also hold anthocyanin, so the red is no longer masked by green. In Triostar this happens in the variegated patches of both faces [1]. In Magic Star, by its description, the cream patches stay cream and only the underside is dark [1]. Whether that difference lies in where anthocyanin is made, or how much, has not been measured in either form; this reading is an inference from the pigments, not a published result.
Light changes the picture. Across land plants, strong light together with a second stress such as cold or drought is a common trigger for red pigment [10], and the 'Valmic' patent warns that its phenotype may vary with temperature and light intensity without any change in genotype [4]. A Triostar grown in dim light can therefore show little pink and look like a Magic Star on the shop shelf, while a Magic Star given strong light is not documented to turn pink. For this reason a single plant in poor light is a weak basis for naming.
Is Magic Star the same plant as 'Valmic'?
No document located connects them, and none connects Triostar to 'Valmic' either. The patent names its plant 'Valmic', classifies it as Stromanthe sanguinea, and describes a naturally occurring mutation found in 1999 in Honselersdijk, the Netherlands, in a crop of the unpatented, solid-green cultivar 'Stripestar' [4]. It does not use the words Triostar or Magic Star [4].
The descriptions overlap enough to make either link plausible and too little to prove one. The 'Valmic' patent mentions no pink, and its phrase green and creamy white with purple lower surfaces [4] is close to the Magic Star wording of creamy white with maroon undersides [1]. Equally, plants sold as Triostar in low light can lose their pink. Similar-looking selections could also have arisen more than once, since a single plant mutation in a crop, as with 'Valmic', is the documented route to these forms [4]. Until a propagator or patent holder publishes which clone each trade name covers, the registry keeps the three names apart.
Do Triostar and Magic Star need different care?
No. Both are Stromanthe thalia, a terrestrial herb of Brazil's Atlantic Forest from Bahia to Paraná [6], and the species' needs follow from that understorey habitat. UF/IFAS Extension identifies high humidity as the key requirement for Triostar and warns that too much sun burns the leaves into brown splotches [2]. The RHS advises partial shade and moist but well-drained, acid to neutral soil for the species [8].
The one biological difference to expect is in vigour. Cream and white tissue carries no working chloroplasts [9], so a leaf with a larger share of variegation has less area for photosynthesis and less green tissue to pay for new growth. That applies to any heavily variegated plant of either name, rather than to one trade form. Reversion also applies to both: an all-green shoot from the base will outgrow the variegated ones, as explained on the variegation-loss page.
How can the two be told apart in a shop?
Turn the plant toward good light and check three things. First, the upper face: pink anywhere in the variegated patches points to Triostar; cream and white only points to Magic Star [1]. Second, the underside: Triostar's is pink to burgundy and itself patterned with pink [1], while Magic Star's is described as a darker maroon [1]. Third, the newest leaves, which show the colour the plant is making under current conditions, since the phenotype shifts with light [4].
Check the genus too. NC State notes that Stromanthe thalia is often confused with Ctenanthe oppenheimiana [1], whose variegated form is also sold as Tricolor. A Ctenanthe carries its flowers in tight, cone-like heads low on the plant, unlike the loose red heads of Stromanthe; the Triostar identification page covers the vegetative differences.
Frequently asked questions
Is Magic Star the same as Triostar?
No, by their published descriptions. Triostar has pink in the variegation and a pink-variegated underside; Magic Star has creamy white variegation without pink and a maroon underside [1]. Both are forms of Stromanthe thalia [1][6].
Is Magic Star a patented Stromanthe?
No patent for a Stromanthe named Magic Star was located as of 2026-10-08. The only patented variegated Stromanthe thalia found is 'Valmic', PP15475, which does not use the name [4].
Why has my Triostar lost its pink?
Low light is the usual cause, because red pigment production depends on light [10] and the patented 'Valmic' phenotype is stated to vary with light and temperature [4]. A plant that sends up all-green shoots is reverting instead.
Which is easier to grow, Triostar or Magic Star?
Neither, on the evidence. They are the same species with the same needs: humidity, filtered light and moist, well-drained soil [2][8]. Plants with more cream tissue have less green leaf area [9] and can be slower.