Hoya carnosa vs Hoya pubicalyx: how to tell the two wax plants apart · ← Hoya Updated 2026-10-09

HOYA

Hoya carnosa vs Hoya pubicalyx: how to tell the two wax plants apart

Two closely related climbing hoyas from opposite ends of a climate gradient, separated by leaf tip, vein count, calyx hairs and corona.


Short answer

Look at the leaf tip and the veins first. Hoya carnosa has ovate to elliptic leaves with an obtuse or short-pointed tip and about four pairs of obscure side veins [3]; H. pubicalyx has longer, oblong leaves, 10 to 14 cm, with a distinctly acuminate tip and about six pairs [4]. In flower, H. pubicalyx has pubescent sepals and pedicels and a slightly retuse corona tip [4]. Carnosa is subtropical, from southern China to southern Japan [1]; pubicalyx is a wet-tropical climber from Luzon [2].

Why are the two so often mixed up?

Because they are close relatives that grow, climb and flower in much the same way. Randal's review of the infrageneric groups of Hoya places H. carnosa, the type of the genus, and H. pubicalyx together in section Hoya, a small group of five or six clear species running from southern China through Thailand to the Philippines [6]. Earlier, C. M. Burton had grouped H. carnosa, H. compacta and H. pubicalyx in one subsection of species that conform closely to H. carnosa [6]. Members share densely pubescent, rotate (flat, wheel-shaped) corollas and convex to globular flower clusters [6].

DNA tells the same story. Wanntorp, Kocyan and Renner found that one ITS sequence of H. carnosa, a stretch of nuclear ribosomal DNA, grouped with a sequence from the morphologically similar H. pubicalyx, which they read as either recent hybridization or old gene copies kept through speciation [5]. The trade added its own confusion: the speckled pubicalyx now registered as 'Silver Pink' was first sold as Hoya purpureofusca, and was only reassigned to H. pubicalyx by Burton in 1987 [7]. Both species also have spotted forms, as the next sections show, so silver flecks prove nothing.

How do they differ, trait by trait?

The table sets the Flora of China account of H. carnosa beside Merrill's 1918 protologue (the original published description) of H. pubicalyx, with Kew's range data for both.

TraitHoya carnosaHoya pubicalyx
Native rangeSouthern China to Laos, southern Kyushu in Japan, and Taiwan [1]Philippines (Luzon) only [2]
Biome and habitatSubtropical; climbing epiphyte or lithophyte [1]; mountain forests, usually on trees, 200 to 1,200 m [3]Wet tropical climber [2]; type collected on trees along streams in damp forest [4]
Leaf shapeBroadly ovate-cordate to ovate-oblong or elliptic, 3.5 to 13 by 3 to 5 cm [3]Oblong to oblong-obovate, 10 to 14 by 3 to 5 cm [4]
Leaf base and tipBase rounded to shallowly cordate; apex obtuse or short acuminate [3]Base obtuse; apex distinctly acuminate [4]
Side veinsAbout 4 pairs, obscure [3]About 6 on each side, indistinct [4]
HairsGlabrous except the inflorescence, which is pubescent [3]Glabrous except the inflorescence; pedicels sparingly appressed-pubescent, sepals pubescent outside [4]
Flower size and colourCorolla 1.5 to 2 cm across, white, sometimes with a pink centre [3]About 1.8 cm across, fragrant [4]; cultivated forms red to maroon [8][9]
Corona lobesOuter angle acute, prominent middle ridge, margin reflexed around a hollow base [3]Oblong-ovate, acuminate, about 5 mm, outer tip slightly retuse, upper surface plano-convex and keeled [4]

What does the name pubicalyx actually describe?

A hairy calyx. The epithet joins the Latin pubes, down, to calyx, the ring of sepals below the corolla. Merrill described the calyx segments of H. pubicalyx as externally somewhat pubescent, about 4 mm long, and the slender pedicels as sparingly appressed-pubescent, the hairs lying flat against the stalk [4]. When he separated the new species, though, he compared it with Hoya luzonica, not with H. carnosa, and he used three characters together: larger flowers, the pubescent pedicels and sepals, and the shape of the corona segments [4].

That matters for anyone using the name as a key. The Flora of China describes H. carnosa as glabrous except for the inflorescences, and its flower clusters as pubescent [3]; Merrill used almost the same words for H. pubicalyx, entirely glabrous except the inflorescence [4]. Some hair on the flower stalks is therefore expected in both. No published side-by-side measurement of calyx hairs in the two species was located as of 2026-10-09, so a hand lens on the sepals is a supporting check, not a decisive one. The leaf and corona carry more weight.

Which leaf characters separate them out of flower?

Three, used together. First the tip: a H. pubicalyx leaf narrows to a distinctly acuminate point [4], where a H. carnosa leaf is obtuse or only shortly pointed [3]. Second the outline: carnosa leaves are widest near the base, broadly ovate and often slightly heart-shaped at the base [3], while pubicalyx leaves are oblong to slightly wider above the middle, with an obtuse base [4]. Third the veins: hold a leaf to the light and count the side veins on one side of the midrib, about four in H. carnosa [3] and about six in H. pubicalyx [4].

Leaf length helps only at the extremes. Both species reach 13 to 14 cm, but carnosa leaves start at 3.5 cm [3] and pubicalyx leaves at 10 cm [4] in these descriptions. Merrill also recorded internodes, the stem lengths between leaf pairs, of up to 20 cm in H. pubicalyx [4], so a pubicalyx vine tends to look longer-jointed.

Speckling is useless here. H. carnosa var. gushanica, a wild Chinese variety, is defined partly by leaves densely or sparsely maculate (spotted) on the upper surface [3], and the speckled pubicalyx 'Silver Pink' arose when a green plant sported to the speckled form [7]. Both species can be green or silvered.

How do the flowers compare?

The structure is similar, as expected in one section, but the corona differs in detail. In H. carnosa each corona lobe has an acute outer angle, a prominent middle ridge, and a margin so strongly reflexed that it encloses a hollow space at the base [3]. Merrill's H. pubicalyx corona measured 10 to 12 mm across, with leathery, shining lobes about 5 mm long, acuminate, slightly retuse (notched) at the outer tip and somewhat keeled along the middle of the upper surface [4]. Both corollas are rotate and densely papillose inside [3][4].

Colour is the most visible difference in cultivated plants but the least reliable in principle. H. carnosa is white, sometimes with a pink centre [3]. Merrill could record only that his dried flowers were brown [4]. The register's cultivated pubicalyx clones run darker: records for 'Bright One' quote reports of olive leaves and bright red flowers, and a 1998 note of colour varying from bluish red to bright firecracker red [8], and a 1978 marketing photograph of PINK SILVER shows maroon flowers [9]. A dark red umbel therefore points toward pubicalyx, but a pale one does not rule it out.

Does the difference matter for care and for pets?

For care, yes, because the two come from different climates. Hoya carnosa is a subtropical species reaching southern Kyushu [1], growing on trees in mountain forest up to 1,200 m [3]; a plant from that range takes a cooler winter in its stride. Hoya pubicalyx is a wet-tropical Luzon climber [2] whose type grew on trees along streams in damp forest [4]. It is better kept warm and evenly humid through winter, with the potting mix allowed to dry only partly between waterings. Both are vigorous: Randal notes that species of section Hoya can become quite large and that some do not bloom until fairly mature [6], so give either one a long support and leave the flowering spurs in place.

For pets, the ASPCA plant database lists both. Its Honey Plant entry, also called Wax Plant, Hoya carnosa, is listed as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses [11]. Its Silver Pink Vine entry, printed as Hoya publcalyx and filed under the old family name Asclepiadaceae, carries the same non-toxic listing for dogs, cats and horses [10].

Frequently asked questions

Is Hoya pubicalyx a type of Hoya carnosa?

No. It is a separate species described by Merrill from Luzon in 1918 [4] and accepted by Kew [2]. The two are close relatives in section Hoya [6], and one DNA study found a shared ITS sequence that may reflect hybridization [5].

Can I tell them apart without flowers?

Usually. Hoya pubicalyx leaves are oblong with a distinctly acuminate tip and about six pairs of side veins [4]; H. carnosa leaves are ovate to elliptic, obtuse or short-pointed, with about four pairs [3].

Do silver speckles mean my plant is pubicalyx?

No. Speckled forms exist in both. The wild Hoya carnosa var. gushanica has spotted upper leaf surfaces [3], and the speckled H. pubicalyx 'Silver Pink' sported from a green plant [7].

Which of the two tolerates cooler rooms?

Hoya carnosa. Kew classes it as subtropical, reaching southern Japan [1], with mountain forest habitats up to 1,200 m [3]. Hoya pubicalyx is a wet-tropical species of Luzon [2].

Are both on the ASPCA non-toxic list?

Yes. ASPCA lists Hoya carnosa (Honey Plant) [11] and Silver Pink Vine, printed as Hoya publcalyx [10], as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses.

See an error, or have documentation we lack? Submissions open shortly. Corrections are reviewed against documentation before the record changes.

Sources

  1. Hoya carnosa (L.f.) R.Br., Plants of the World Online (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:107308-3 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  2. Hoya pubicalyx Merr., Plants of the World Online (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:98653-1 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  3. Hoya carnosa (Linnaeus f.) R. Brown, Flora of China Vol. 16 (1995-01-01). Flora of China (eFloras). http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=2&taxon_id=200018633 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  4. Merrill, E.D. (1918). Hoya pubicalyx sp. nov. Philippine Journal of Science, C (Botany) 13: 331-332 (1918-01-01). Bureau of Science, Manila (Internet Archive scan). https://archive.org/details/philippinejo131918phil Accessed 2026-10-09.
  5. Wanntorp, L., Kocyan, A. & Renner, S.S. (2006). Wax plants disentangled: a phylogeny of Hoya (Marsdenieae, Apocynaceae) inferred from nuclear and chloroplast DNA sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 39: 722-733 (2006-06-01). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2006.01.022 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  6. Randal, M. (2008). A look at Hoya sections, part 1. Stemma 2(3): 10-52 (2008-01-01). Stemma Journal. https://stemmajournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/StemmaV2_3.pdf Accessed 2026-10-09.
  7. 'Silver Pink' (Hoya pubicalyx), cultivar record (2024-04-03). HoyaCultivars.org, International Cultivar Registration Authority for Hoya. https://hoyacultivars.org/silver-pink/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  8. 'Bright One' (Hoya pubicalyx), cultivar record (2024-04-14). HoyaCultivars.org, International Cultivar Registration Authority for Hoya. https://hoyacultivars.org/bright-one/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  9. PINK SILVER (Hoya pubicalyx), trade designation record (2024-06-26). HoyaCultivars.org, International Cultivar Registration Authority for Hoya. https://hoyacultivars.org/pink-silver/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  10. Silver Pink Vine (Hoya publcalyx [sic]), Toxic and Non-Toxic Plants (n.d.). ASPCA Animal Poison Control. https://www.aspca.org/pet-care/animal-poison-control/toxic-and-non-toxic-plants/silver-pink-vine Accessed 2026-10-09.
  11. Honey Plant (Hoya carnosa), Toxic and Non-Toxic Plants (n.d.). ASPCA Animal Poison Control. https://www.aspca.org/pet-care/animal-poison-control/toxic-and-non-toxic-plants/honey-plant Accessed 2026-10-09.

Published by Rytas Dirse, Solo Founder & AI Architect

Built with AI, held to quality gates. US sources, US brands, facts only.

How this page was made

Digital Towns uses AI assistance to research and write its guides, and every page is only as good as the sources it cites. Our goal is the most accurate, useful local information possible.

This page was fact-checked twice before publishing.

If you see an error, or anything you can show is false, tell us right away and we will take a third look.

Report an error
Quote or describe the part that's wrong.
Explain what's actually true.
Only if you'd like a reply. Never shown publicly.

How we fact-check