Short answer
Compacta rope hoyas have leaves folded and recurved into near-closed shapes that overlap along short internodes; 'Krinkle 8' has broad, open leaves with six to ten dimples, spaced well apart [3][1]. Both are Hoya carnosa cultivars said to descend from 'Exotica' [2][3]. 'Krinkle 8' was patented by Lloyd Magnuson in 1970; Hummel, credited with 'Compacta', patented nothing [3][2].
Why are Compacta and 'Krinkle 8' mixed up?
Both plants are Hoya carnosa with distorted leaves, and the labels around them have been loose for sixty years. 'Compacta' is the original green clone of the registry's Hoya carnosa Compacta Group, the rope hoyas whose contorted leaves grow around the vine and around one another [1]. 'Krinkle 8' is an accepted cultivar outside that Group, named for the dimples in its leaf blades [4].
They may also be relatives. Laurence Hatch, quoted in Conroy's 2022 history in Stemma Journal, calls the Hindu rope plant, H. carnosa 'Compacta', a twisted leaf sport on Ed Hummel's cultivar 'Exotica' [2]. Lloyd Magnuson's patent for 'Krinkle 8' states that it developed from a mutation on a plant of the Hoya Carnosa Exotica variety [3]. 'Exotica' is a variegated carnosa with leaves predominantly white, edged irregularly with two shades of light green [6]. If Hatch is right, both odd-leaved cultivars are green mutants of the same parent, which would explain why their flowers look so alike at a glance. Conroy treats the Compacta origin as unresolved, so this is one documented account, not a settled pedigree [2].
The names add to the muddle. Conroy notes that Krinkle Kurl was used to sell 'Compacta' as well as the separate 'Hummel's Krinkle Kurl' [2], while 'Ripple', an invalid trade designation, is used for 'Krinkle 8' [7]. ASPCA's database has a Wax Plant entry labelled Hoya carnosa 'krinkle kurl' with Hindu Rope Plant as another common name [8]. A buyer searching for hoya krinkle can land on either plant.
How do they differ, trait by trait?
Magnuson's patent compares the two directly, and the Compacta columns draw on the patents for Cobia's Compacta sports, which describe themselves as structurally like the green parent.
| Trait | Compacta Group (green 'Compacta') | 'Krinkle 8' |
|---|---|---|
| Leaf posture | Strongly conduplicate (folded lengthwise) and recurved, often nearly closed, with bent midribs drawing the tips toward the stem [3] | Open, broad, ovate blade [3] |
| Leaf surface | Smooth; the underside is what shows, because the blade folds [2] | Six to ten dimples beside the midrib, raised on the underside [3] |
| Internodes | About 8 to 30 mm in the Compacta-structured 'Marginalis' [5]; leaves overlap into a rope [1] | Usually 20 to 45 mm; leaf pairs stand apart [3] |
| Flowers | Smaller, on shorter and thinner pedicels [3]; corona lobes broader and shorter per Burton [2] | 16 to 19 mm across, on longer, thicker pedicels, 20 to 35 per umbel [3] |
| Origin | Hummel's Exotic Gardens, California; dated to 1952 by Minnie Belle Hummel [2] | Mutation found by Lloyd S. Magnuson, Leesburg, Florida; filed 1968 [3] |
| Legal status | Never patented; Hummel patented none of his cultivars [2] | US Plant Patent 3,008, assigned to B. L. Cobia, Inc. [3] |
The single quickest check is the upper leaf surface. On a Compacta it is mostly hidden: C.M. Burton described the leaves as folded and sometimes folded again, with the under surfaces exposed and the upper surfaces hidden [2]. On 'Krinkle 8' the upper surface faces the light and carries the dimples.
What does each leaf shape mean for the plant?
Wild Hoya carnosa is built for spacing. In Taiwan's Fushan forest, Martin, Hsu and Lin (2009) noted that leaf pairs are widely separated on the shoots of H. carnosa, and that leaf thickness varied with the light reaching each leaf along the vine [9]. 'Krinkle 8', with internodes of 20 to 45 mm and open blades [3], keeps something close to that wild architecture: each leaf pair is held clear of the next and can intercept light on its upper surface.
The Compacta reverses it. Its short internodes stack the leaves, and the fold turns much of the blade inside out [1]. Leaves overlap and shade one another, and the green tissue that does the work faces inward. That costs growth: a rope packs many leaves into a short length of stem but fixes less carbon per leaf than an open-leaved carnosa in the same light. It also creates still, humid pockets between leaves. Hatch, quoted by Conroy, observed that the Compacta may be the mealy bug's favourite hiding place [2], and NC State Extension lists mealybugs among the common insect problems of Hoya carnosa [10].
The flowers differ less than the leaves, but Burton saw a real difference. Writing in 1990, she found that the Compacta's corona lobes, the five waxy horns at the centre of each flower, are much broader and shorter and lack the keel-like ridge seen in ordinary H. carnosa [2]. Conroy suggests that such differences could point to a hybrid or to the radiation work long rumoured around these nurseries [2].
Which care differences follow from the shapes?
Both are Hoya carnosa, so the basics match: a loose, fast-draining mix allowed to dry between waterings, and protection once nights fall below 50 °F (10 °C), as NC State Extension advises for the species [10]. Magnuson grew 'Krinkle 8' under 85% shade in Central Florida, with winters of about 60 to 85 °F [3], and Cobia's Compacta sports were grown under the same 85% shade regime [5].
- Light. A Compacta's inward-facing leaves need brighter filtered light to grow at a useful rate than the open leaves of 'Krinkle 8', which present their upper surface directly.
- Drying. A dense rope holds moisture among its leaves and dries slowly; give the pot time to dry and water the mix, not the rope. 'Krinkle 8' dries more evenly.
- Pests. Inspect inside the folds of a Compacta with a hand lens; on 'Krinkle 8', check the dimples and leaf undersides, where the waxy, glaucous surface sits [3].
- Training. A Compacta hangs as a rope and rarely needs support. 'Krinkle 8' twines and climbs like the wild species, so a hoop or trellis keeps its spaced leaves on show.
The Hindu rope care page goes further into Compacta culture, and the 'Krinkle 8' page covers that cultivar's patent description and flowers in full.
Which names on the label are wrong?
Hoya compacta is the commonest. C.M. Burton published it as a species in 1990, but the registry describes that publication as illegitimate, because it described an established cultivar as a species; the plants are Hoya carnosa Compacta Group [1]. Hindu rope is not a cultivar name either: it is an expired trademark that B.L.Cobia, Inc. used to sell 'Compacta', with the application filed in August 1966 [2].
On the other side, 'Krinkle 8' is correct, 'Krinkle-8' is an accepted synonym, and 'Ripple' should be replaced with the cultivar name [4][7]. Krinkle Kurl belongs, in Conroy's reading, only to 'Hummel's Krinkle Kurl', a tighter-curled Hummel clone related to 'Compacta' [2]. So a plant labelled Hoya krinkle that forms a twisted rope is a Compacta Group plant; one with open, dimpled leaves is 'Krinkle 8'.
Frequently asked questions
Is 'Krinkle 8' a type of Hoya compacta?
No. 'Krinkle 8' arose as a mutation on 'Exotica' and has open, broad, dimpled leaves [3]. The Compacta Group is defined by contorted leaves growing around the vine and one another [1].
Which one flowers more easily?
No controlled comparison was found. 'Krinkle 8' carries larger flowers on longer pedicels than compacta, per its patent [3], and its open leaves catch more light per leaf, which favours the mature, well-lit growth that flowering needs.
Are Compacta and 'Krinkle 8' the same species?
Both are cultivars of Hoya carnosa. The name Hoya compacta was published as a species in 1990, but the registry treats that as illegitimate [1].
What is 'Hummel's Krinkle Kurl'?
A separate rope-type clone from Hummel's Exotic Gardens with tighter curls than 'Compacta'; A.B. Graf described it as monstrose, with very green leaves folded and then recoiled [2]. It is not 'Krinkle 8'.
Can a 'Krinkle 8' turn into a Compacta?
There is no record of it. Each is propagated by cuttings and stays true; 'Krinkle 8' was described from plants grown on from cuttings of the original mutation [3].