Hoya vs Dischidia: two related epiphytic milkweeds · ← Hoya Updated 2026-10-09

HOYA

Hoya vs Dischidia: two related epiphytic milkweeds

How to tell a hoya from a dischidia by flower, leaf and habit, why DNA has not fully separated them, and how their ant habits differ.


Short answer

Hoya and Dischidia are sister lineages of epiphytic climbers in the milkweed subfamily of Apocynaceae, both named by Robert Brown in 1810 [1] [4]. Hoyas have open, star-shaped waxy flowers with a prominent corona; dischidias have small, urn-shaped flowers with a ring of hairs at the mouth [4] [3]. Dischidia has about 80 species against more than 500 in Hoya [3] [6], and it includes the pitcher-leaved ant plants.

How closely related are Hoya and Dischidia?

Very closely. Both belong to tribe Marsdenieae of subfamily Asclepiadoideae, the former milkweed family Asclepiadaceae now merged into Apocynaceae. Robert Brown published both genus names in the same work, his 1810 Prodromus Florae Novae Hollandiae, where Dischidia appears on page 461 [1] and Hoya on page 459 [4]. Together with a handful of small genera they form what botanists call the Hoya group: Rodda and Niissalo list Absolmsia, Anatropanthus, Clemensiella, Dischidia (about 80 species), Heynella, Madangia, Micholitzia and Oreosparte as its traditional members [6].

The DNA evidence has never cleanly separated the two big genera. An early chloroplast study by Wanntorp and colleagues found that Hoya and Dischidia form a monophyletic group (one lineage with a single common ancestor), but the data were insufficient to support each genus as monophyletic on its own [5]. Later plastome work by Rodda and Niissalo placed Papuahoya as the earliest branch of the Hoya group, then Dischidia, with the link between Dischidia and the Hoya plus Oreosparte clade not fully supported [6]. A 2026 analysis of 76 Marsdenieae plastomes found Dischidia itself strongly monophyletic, yet the relationships among Dischidia, Oreosparte and the two main Hoya clades remained unresolved [8].

Hoya and Dischidia side by side

TraitHoyaDischidia
Accepted species566 in Plants of the World Online [9]About 80 [3] [6]
Native rangeTropical and subtropical Asia to the western Pacific [10]Tropical and subtropical Asia to the western Pacific [2]
CorollaFleshy, rotate (flat and wheel-shaped) or reflexed [4]Small, more or less urceolate (urn-shaped), with a ring of hairs inside the mouth [3]
CoronaFive fleshy lobes with revolute (rolled-under) margins [4]Anchor-shaped staminal corona [3]
LeavesOpposite, fleshy, papery or membranous [4]; often largeOpposite; often small and fleshy; in some species pitcher-shaped or dome-shaped ant leaves [3]
PhotosynthesisCAM in fleshy-leaved species [11]CAM in fleshy-leaved species [11]
Ant partnershipsLeaf domatia, leaf shields, ant gardens, ant cavities [12]Pitcher leaves, dome leaves, ant gardens, ant cavities [3] [13]

The table shows why the two are confused: same range, same climbing epiphytic habit, same night-time CAM photosynthesis, same umbels of small waxy flowers. The flower is the reliable separator [3] [4].

How do you tell a hoya flower from a dischidia flower?

Look into the flower. A hoya corolla opens flat or bends back, and its centre carries a raised five-pointed corona whose lobes have rolled-under outer margins, a character the Flora of China treatment builds into its genus description [4]. A dischidia flower barely opens: the corolla is a small urn, usually closed at the throat by a ring of hairs, with an anchor-shaped corona hidden inside [3]. The flowers are small [3], so a hand lens helps.

The boundary is not perfectly clean. Hoya corymbosa, described from Sabah in 2013, has minute corona lobes without revolute margins and broad, flat pollinarium caudicles (the arms joining the pollen sacs) resembling those of Dischidia, yet DNA confirmed it as a Hoya [7]. For the parts of a hoya flower in detail, see hoya flowers.

How do their leaves and growth differ?

The clearest field comparison comes from Taiwan, where Martin, Hsu and Lin measured both genera on the same host trees. Leaves of Dischidia formosana were small and oval, about 1 cm across and thickest at the centre, while Hoya carnosa leaves were typically 10 to 20 cm long [11]. Hoya leaf pairs sit far apart along the shoot, whereas dischidia leaf pairs grow close together [11]. A trailing dischidia is therefore a dense rope of small coin-like leaves; a hoya is a looser vine of larger leaves with long bare internodes.

Both, however, are leaf succulents running crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), the night-time photosynthesis of water-saving plants. Martin and colleagues chose these two species because both are obligate CAM plants, and in both the amount of CAM did not track leaf thickness [11]. Winter and colleagues had earlier found CAM in Asclepiadaceae in exactly these two genera, both of which usually have fleshy leaves [14]. That shared physiology is why the care advice for the two converges; see hoya succulent leaves.

Which genus has the stronger ant partnerships?

Dischidia, by a short head. Its best-known species, Dischidia major, has pitcher leaves used as nest sites by arboreal ants [13]. Other species shelter ants under round leaves convex above and concave below [3]. Within Dischidia, the ant-house species D. milnei, once placed in a separate genus Conchophyllum, nests in the same clade as the type species D. nummularia [6], so ant leaves are part of the core of the genus. In D. major, up to 39 percent of the carbon the plant uses may come from ant-associated sources [15]. Some dischidias also carry oil-rich structures in their seeds that attract ants [13].

Hoya has the same toolkit in fewer species. Kleijn and van Donkelaar note that housing ants under imbricate (overlapping) leaves, as Hoya imbricata does, is more commonly seen in Dischidia [12], and they found Dischidia species growing on the same ant nests as Hoya brevialata in central Sulawesi [12]. The partnership can also skip the obvious ant plants: on those nests, the pitcher-leaved D. major was poorly correlated with ant nests, whereas the unspecialised D. nummularia and H. brevialata were strongly correlated [12]. For the hoya side, see ant hoyas.

Leaf shape alone does not prove an ant partnership in Dischidia either. In Malaysian montane forest, Weir and Kiew found that the leathery, dome-shaped leaves of D. astephana were not used as nests; ants of the genus Crematogaster lived in tunnels in the wood of the host tree instead, and the roots of D. astephana and the lens-leaved D. parvifolia grew into those tunnels to feed on nest waste [18]. The dome leaves may still help by catching stem flow and debris beneath them [18]. The same root-in-cavity habit turns up in Hoya myrmecopa in Sulawesi [12], one more trait the two genera share.

Will a Dischidia grow like a Hoya?

Largely, with adjustments for size. Both are epiphytic CAM climbers of the same Asian and Pacific range [2] [10], so both want a fast-draining, airy root zone and dry spells between waterings. The small, closely spaced leaves of a dischidia [11] hold less water per leaf than the broad leaf of H. carnosa, so a dischidia in a small basket dries faster and needs closer watching. The pitchers of D. major serve as ant nests in the wild [13]; indoors they house no colony, so the plant forgoes that nutrient source and relies on its potting medium. Flowers are the main difference for a grower: a hoya is grown for showy umbels, a dischidia for foliage, its flowers being tiny urns [3].

Frequently asked questions

Is Dischidia a type of Hoya?

No, it is a separate genus, though the two are sister lineages in the same tribe. DNA studies have not fully resolved their relationship, but they recover Dischidia as a well-supported lineage of its own [8] [6].

Can Hoya and Dischidia hybridise?

No record of a hybrid between the two genera was located in the literature reviewed for this page. Their very different flower structures, open corolla and exposed corona in Hoya versus a hair-closed urn in Dischidia [4] [3], make cross-pollination unlikely.

Where does Dischidia nummularia come from?

Dischidia nummularia, the type species of the genus, has small round leaves; its epithet comes from the Latin for a small coin. It was described by Robert Brown in 1810 and is native from southern China to tropical Asia and northern Queensland [16].

Do both genera have milky sap?

Sap is a poor character for telling them apart. Within Hoya alone it varies: Hoya carnosa and some relatives lack coloured latex [17], while other species have it.

See an error, or have documentation we lack? Submissions open shortly. Corrections are reviewed against documentation before the record changes.

Sources

  1. Dischidia R.Br., Prodr. Fl. Nov. Holland. 461 (1810), name record (n.d.). International Plant Names Index. https://www.ipni.org/api/1/n/60474363-2 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  2. Dischidia R.Br., World Checklist of Vascular Plants record (GBIF checklist 206555845) (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, via GBIF. https://api.gbif.org/v1/species/206555845 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  3. A new species of Dischidia (Apocynaceae, Asclepiadoideae) from North-eastern Thailand (W. Promprom & W. Chatan), PhytoKeys 144: 23-30 (2020-01-01). Pensoft, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7093575/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  4. Hoya, Flora of China vol. 16: 228 (1995-01-01). eFloras (Missouri Botanical Garden and Harvard University Herbaria). http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=2&taxon_id=115819 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  5. Towards a monophyletic Hoya (Marsdenieae, Apocynaceae): inferences from the chloroplast trnL region and the rbcL-atpB spacer (L. Wanntorp, A. Kocyan, R. van Donkelaar & S. S. Renner), Systematic Botany 31: 586-596 (2006-01-01). American Society of Plant Taxonomists (abstract via Europe PMC). https://doi.org/10.1600/036364406778388593 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  6. Plastome evolution and organisation in the Hoya group (Apocynaceae) (M. Rodda & M. A. Niissalo), Scientific Reports 11: 14520 (2021-01-01). Springer Nature, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8282776/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  7. Hoya corymbosa (Apocynaceae, Asclepiadoideae), a new unusual species from Sabah, Borneo, and its systematic position based on phylogenetic analysis (M. Rodda, N. S. Juhonewe & E. Ercole), Systematic Botany 38: 1125-1131 (2013-01-01). American Society of Plant Taxonomists (abstract via Europe PMC). https://doi.org/10.1600/036364413x674733 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  8. Phylogenomic and comparative analyses of plastomes of the tribe Marsdenieae (Apocynaceae: Asclepiadoideae) (R. Chen et al.), BMC Plant Biology 26: 1347 (2026-01-01). BioMed Central, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13455222/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  9. Hoya R.Br. (n.d.). Plants of the World Online, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:60437256-2 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  10. Hoya R.Br., World Checklist of Vascular Plants record (GBIF checklist 206543600) (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, via GBIF. https://api.gbif.org/v1/species/206543600 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  11. The relationship between CAM and leaf succulence in two epiphytic vines, Hoya carnosa and Dischidia formosana (C. E. Martin, R. Hsu & T.-C. Lin), Photosynthetica 47(3): 445-450 (2009-09-01). Institute of Experimental Botany, Czech Academy of Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11099-009-0068-6 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  12. Notes on the taxonomy and ecology of the genus Hoya (Asclepiadaceae) in Central Sulawesi (D. Kleijn & R. van Donkelaar), Blumea 46(3): 457-483 (2001-01-01). Naturalis Biodiversity Center. https://repository.naturalis.nl/pub/524796/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  13. Analysis of the complete plastomes of 31 species of Hoya group: insights into their comparative genomics and phylogenetic relationships (W. O. Odago et al.), Frontiers in Plant Science 12: 814833 (2022-01-01). Frontiers, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8862764/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  14. Crassulacean acid metabolism in Australian vascular epiphytes and some related species (K. Winter, B. J. Wallace, G. C. Stocker & Z. Roksandic), Oecologia 57: 129-141 (1983-03-01). Springer (abstract via Europe PMC). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00379570 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  15. The carbon isotope composition of epiphytes depends not only on their layers, life forms, and taxonomical groups but also on the carbon and nitrogen indicators of host trees (A. K. Eskov et al.), Plants 12: 3500 (2023-01-01). MDPI, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10575002/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  16. Dischidia nummularia R.Br., World Checklist of Vascular Plants record (GBIF checklist 206556135) (n.d.). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, via GBIF. https://api.gbif.org/v1/species/206556135 Accessed 2026-10-09.
  17. Two new species of Hoya R.Br. (Apocynaceae, Asclepiadoideae) from Borneo (M. Rodda), PhytoKeys 53: 83-93 (2015-07-21). Pensoft, via PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4547025/ Accessed 2026-10-09.
  18. A reassessment of the relations in Malaysia between ants (Crematogaster) on trees (Leptospermum and Dacrydium) and epiphytes of the genus Dischidia (Asclepiadaceae) including 'ant-plants' (J. S. Weir & R. Kiew), Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 27: 113-132 (1986-01-01). Oxford University Press (abstract via Europe PMC). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1095-8312.1986.tb01729.x Accessed 2026-10-09.

Published by Rytas Dirse, Solo Founder & AI Architect

Built with AI, held to quality gates. US sources, US brands, facts only.

How this page was made

Digital Towns uses AI assistance to research and write its guides, and every page is only as good as the sources it cites. Our goal is the most accurate, useful local information possible.

This page was fact-checked twice before publishing.

If you see an error, or anything you can show is false, tell us right away and we will take a third look.

Report an error
Quote or describe the part that's wrong.
Explain what's actually true.
Only if you'd like a reply. Never shown publicly.

How we fact-check